Responding to Reviewers · Module 05 of 05

Handling disagreement and difficult comments

This module covers when and how to respectfully decline a reviewer's request, supporting disagreement with evidence, and resolving contradictory comments from two reviewers. Handling disagreement well protects both the paper's quality and your professional relationship with the editor.

Watch the first lesson of every module free. The remaining lessons, exercises and live sessions open when you enrol.

What you will be able to do

  • Decide when and how to respectfully decline a reviewer's request
  • Support a disagreement with evidence or citation rather than assertion
  • Resolve contradictory comments from two reviewers
  • Recognise when to appeal an editor's decision

Key terms

  • Respectful disagreement
  • Contradictory comments
  • Editorial appeal

Hands-on practice

Write a response to a comment you believe is mistaken, supporting your position with a citation or a point of evidence, while remaining respectful.

Common pitfalls this module fixes

  • Ignoring a comment you disagree with instead of addressing it; silence reads as evasion, so explain your reasoning even when declining.
  • Playing two reviewers' contradictory comments against each other without flagging the contradiction to the editor; name it and explain your resolution.