Responding to Reviewers · Module 01 of 05

Reading the decision letter and reviewer comments

This module covers identifying the editor's decision type, separating the editor's comments from each reviewer's, and recognising which comments are mandatory versus suggestions. How you read the letter shapes how well you respond to it.

Watch the first lesson of every module free. The remaining lessons, exercises and live sessions open when you enrol.

What you will be able to do

  • Identify the editor's decision type: minor revision, major revision, or reject and resubmit
  • Separate the editor's comments from each individual reviewer's comments
  • Recognise which comments are mandatory and which are suggestions
  • Manage your reaction to criticism before drafting a response

Key terms

  • Decision letter
  • Major revision
  • Minor revision
  • Editor comment
  • Reviewer comment

Hands-on practice

Read a decision letter and reviewer report and highlight, in three colours, what is mandatory, what is a suggestion and what needs clarification from the editor.

Common pitfalls this module fixes

  • Replying to reviewer comments the day they arrive; read them fully, then set them aside before drafting a response.
  • Treating every comment as equally weighted; mandatory requirements from the editor take priority over an individual reviewer's preference.