Responding to Reviewers · Module 02 of 05

Sorting and prioritising reviewer comments

This module covers grouping comments by theme, numbering every comment for traceability, and deciding which comments require new analysis versus clarification. A sorted comment list is what turns an overwhelming letter into a manageable plan.

Watch the first lesson of every module free. The remaining lessons, exercises and live sessions open when you enrol.

What you will be able to do

  • Group comments by theme across reviewers, such as methodology, framing, writing and references
  • Number every comment for a traceable response
  • Decide which comments require new analysis versus clarification
  • Build a response plan and realistic timeline before writing

Key terms

  • Comment grouping
  • Traceability
  • Response plan
  • New analysis

Hands-on practice

Number and group every comment from your reviewers into a table with columns for theme, required action and status.

Common pitfalls this module fixes

  • Responding to comments in the order they were received rather than by theme; grouping avoids repeating the same answer in different words.
  • Underestimating how long a requested new analysis will take; flag it early if a deadline extension is needed.