Identifying the right research gap is the backbone of a PhD dissertation. It gives your study its rationale, leads to strong and relevant research questions, and shows that your work adds something new to your field. Without it, research questions lose focus and the study risks repeating what is already known.
A missing or poorly defined gap has real consequences. Research questions may be weak or repetitive, the thesis may lack justification and originality, and examiners may ask for major revisions or, in the worst case, reject the dissertation. Journals and conferences may also judge the work irrelevant and decline it.
So a poorly defined gap can cost years of work. Many scholars, in the US, UK, Australia, China, Brazil, Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia and elsewhere, find this step hard. Your mentor helps you locate explicit knowledge, methodological and contextual gaps in your area, and place your study on firm academic foundations.