Statistical review and reporting support for journal manuscripts

Manuscript Statistical Review

Mentoring to check, report and justify the statistics in your journal manuscript before you submit.

Struggling to report the statistics in your journal manuscript? Whether you work in medicine, engineering, the social sciences or management, your mentor, a statistician in your field, reviews your methods and results against the target journal's requirements and recognised reporting guidelines, and helps you present effect sizes, confidence intervals, tables and figures clearly and accurately.

Why it matters

Why statistical review matters before submission

Clear, correct statistical reporting is essential for publication. Yet many manuscripts present data poorly: methods are under-described, tables and figures are hard to read, and visuals obscure the key findings. PhD Research Lab mentors researchers in reporting statistical methods and results for quantitative, qualitative and mixed-methods studies, so that the analysis, its interpretation and the Results section match the research objectives and the expectations of peer-reviewed journals.

Poor statistical reporting is a widespread, long-standing problem in academic publishing. Reviews of the published literature have repeatedly found errors in how statistics are applied, interpreted and reported, and such errors can undermine a study's conclusions. From a flawed analysis plan to a misused inferential test, statistical problems can delay publication or lead to rejection.

Your mentor is a statistician with experience of copyediting, statistical reporting and research methodology in your discipline. They explain concepts rather than just supplying output, and guide you on how to interpret, present and defend your results to editors and reviewers.

  1. 01

    Fewer avoidable errors

    A review before submission catches mismatched numbers, unsuitable tests, unchecked assumptions and missing information in Methods and Results.

  2. 02

    Clarity and rigour

    Results that report effect sizes with confidence intervals, not only p-values, are easier for reviewers to judge and readers to use.

  3. 03

    Reporting guidelines

    Many journals require a completed checklist for the relevant guideline, such as CONSORT for randomised trials, STROBE for observational studies or PRISMA for systematic reviews.

  4. 04

    Reproducibility

    Clearly described methods, software versions and data and code availability let others check and build on your work.

  5. 05

    Time saved

    Addressing statistical issues before submission can save rounds of revision, though no service can guarantee acceptance, which is decided by editors and reviewers.

Our approach

What a statistical review for publication covers

Journals, statistical reviewers and readers look for the same things: the right analysis for the design, honestly and completely reported. Your mentor reviews your manuscript against these standards and records every suggested change with its reason.

01

Recognised reporting guidelines

Reporting guidelines, collected by the EQUATOR Network, set out what a paper must report for its study design: CONSORT for randomised trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews and meta-analyses, STARD for diagnostic accuracy studies, TRIPOD for prediction models, ARRIVE for animal research, and COREQ or SRQR for qualitative research. We check your manuscript against the right checklist and help you fill in the page numbers journals ask for.

02

The SAMPL guidelines

The SAMPL guidelines (Statistical Analyses and Methods in the Published Literature, Lang and Altman) give basic rules for reporting statistics in biomedical journals. They ask authors to name and justify each test, confirm its assumptions were checked, report the software used, give exact p-values and report effect sizes with confidence intervals. We use them as a checklist for Methods and Results in any quantitative field.

03

Effect sizes and confidence intervals

A p-value alone says nothing about how large or important an effect is. We help you report the estimate that answers your research question, such as a mean difference, odds ratio (OR), risk ratio (RR), hazard ratio (HR), absolute risk difference or standardised effect size, with its 95% confidence interval and units, and interpret it in practical or clinical terms.

04

Avoiding p-value misuse

The American Statistical Association's 2016 statement on p-values sets out six principles: p-values can show how incompatible data are with a specified model; they do not measure the probability that a hypothesis is true or that the data arose by chance alone; conclusions should not rest only on whether p passes a threshold; proper inference needs full reporting and transparency; a p-value does not measure the size or importance of an effect; and by itself it is not a good measure of evidence. We help you report exact p-values (for example p = 0.032, or p < 0.001 for very small values), avoid describing non-significant results as proof of no effect, and account for multiple comparisons.

05

Assumptions, diagnostics and sensitivity

We check that each test or model suits your data: normality, homoscedasticity, independence and linearity, residuals, variance inflation factors (VIF) for multicollinearity, influential observations and model fit. Pre-specified sensitivity and subgroup analyses are reported as such, and post hoc analyses are labelled as exploratory.

06

Missing data and outliers

The amount of missing data, its likely mechanism and how it was handled, such as complete-case analysis or multiple imputation, must be reported. Outliers are investigated and reported, not removed to change a result; any exclusion needs a stated, justified rule and, ideally, a sensitivity analysis with and without them.

07

Reproducibility and data availability

Many journals require a data availability statement saying where the data and code can be found, or why they cannot be shared, for example for participant confidentiality. We help you describe software and package versions, share an analysis script where possible, deposit data in a suitable repository such as OSF, Zenodo, Dryad or Figshare, and word the statement to the journal's policy.

08

Integrity boundaries

We never fabricate, alter or selectively report data or results, and we do not search for analyses that produce significance. Re-analysis is done only with your own data and your approval, and every change is documented so you can explain it to your co-authors, editors and reviewers. Statistical support should be acknowledged in your manuscript, as journals following ICMJE recommendations expect.

What we support

Manuscript statistical support we offer

We support the statistical content of quantitative, qualitative and mixed-methods manuscripts in clinical, social science, engineering and other fields.

  • 01

    Statistical analysis planning

    Choosing statistical methods that answer your objectives and hypotheses, selecting suitable models (for example linear, logistic, Cox or mixed models) and developing a statistical analysis plan (SAP) that meets journal and ethical requirements.

  • 02

    Statistical Methods section

    Setting out the study design, sample size justification, statistical tests, software and assumptions so that a reviewer could reproduce the analysis.

  • 03

    Results reporting and interpretation

    Turning SPSS, Stata, R, Python or MATLAB output into publication-quality results: descriptive statistics, inferential tests, effect sizes, confidence intervals and p-values, interpreted correctly. Your mentor guides you as you write your own Results and Discussion.

  • 04

    Tables and figures

    Publication-quality tables and figures in R (ggplot2), Python (Matplotlib, seaborn), Excel or GraphPad Prism, adjusted to each journal's requirements: forest plots, Kaplan-Meier curves, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and correlation matrices, with clear labels, colours and resolution.

  • 05

    Reporting guideline compliance

    Checking the manuscript against CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA or another relevant guideline, and against analysis transparency, reproducibility and data integrity.

  • 06

    Statistical quality check and validation

    An independent review of your analysis. With your data and approval, we re-run key analyses to check that the reported numbers can be reproduced, and confirm that the interpretation fits the research objectives and conclusions.

  • 07

    Assumptions and research design review

    Reviewing the assumptions behind each test, running diagnostics such as residual analysis and VIF, and reviewing design features: sampling, control groups, blinding and randomisation.

  • 08

    Advanced and biostatistical models

    Survival analysis, multilevel models, meta-analysis, time series and Bayesian inference; handling missing data, confounding, multicollinearity and model diagnostics; and machine learning or predictive models, reported to TRIPOD where relevant.

  • 09

    Qualitative analysis reporting

    Reporting thematic, content, framework, grounded theory, narrative or phenomenological analysis, coded in NVivo, ATLAS.ti or MAXQDA, with the transparency that COREQ or SRQR expect.

  • 10

    Formatting statistical content

    Formatting ANOVA, regression and survival tables, statistical notation, abbreviations and figures to the journal template and to APA, AMA or journal-specific style.

  • 11

    Reviewer comments on statistics

    Help with statistical comments from reviewers: re-running or extending analyses with your data and approval, and drafting point-by-point responses that you review and submit.

Sample work

Sample work

Examples from our sample library.

What you get

What's included in manuscript statistical review

Here is what we need from you, what the review covers, and what sits outside this service.

What we need from you

Send these with your request.

  • Your manuscript draft, including tables, figures and any supplementary files
  • The name of your target journal and its author guidelines
  • Your software output and, if you would like analyses checked or re-run, your dataset and analysis code
  • Your study protocol, statistical analysis plan or trial registration, if any
  • Any comments from co-authors, editors or reviewers

What's included

Part of every manuscript statistical review order.

  • A consultation with a statistician on your study, timeline and deliverables
  • Review of the statistical Methods and Results against the journal's requirements and the relevant reporting guideline
  • Checks of test choice, assumptions, effect sizes, confidence intervals and p-values
  • Revised, journal-compliant tables and figures
  • Guidance on interpreting and wording your results, and on the data availability statement
  • Revisions within the agreed scope of your package

Not included

Available as add-ons or other services.

Also included with your order

Every manuscript statistics order comes with added support from a mentor in your research area.

Subject experts

Your mentor is a statistician with experience in your discipline, such as medicine and clinical research, engineering, computer science and AI, the life sciences, management and finance, or the social sciences and public policy.

Statistical software

We work in SPSS, SAS, R, Python, Stata, Minitab, GraphPad Prism, JMP and Epi Info, and in NVivo, ATLAS.ti or MAXQDA for qualitative data, matching the software your analysis used.

Referencing

Methodological sources are cited in your journal's style and managed in tools such as Mendeley, Zotero or EndNote, drawing on databases such as Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, IEEE Xplore, JSTOR and ProQuest.

Graphical abstracts

Where your journal asks for one, we can help you prepare a graphical abstract that summarises the main result accurately.

Quality check

Before delivery, the review is checked for consistency between text, tables and figures and for clear language.

Study materials

Where access and copyright allow, we share the methodological articles cited, so you can read the sources yourself.

Find your starting point

Where are you with your manuscript statistics?

Research journeys are rarely straightforward, with hurdles, surprises, hard work, beginnings and endings. PhD Research Lab travels this journey with you, mentoring researchers worldwide.

“I have the SPSS output, but I'm not sure how to interpret the statistics or describe the results.”
WilsonResearcher
How we help Interpreting and reporting your results

Your mentor explains what each number in your output means and helps you report the estimates, confidence intervals and p-values clearly, in the order and format your journal expects.

Usually works best: Hourly mentoring Talk to us
“My journal editor has asked me to explain how I ensured the validity and robustness of my statistical analyses.”
DwayneResearcher
How we help Assumption checks and robustness

We review assumption checks (such as normality and homoscedasticity), reliability measures (such as Cronbach's alpha or the intraclass correlation coefficient) and sensitivity analyses, and help you report them transparently.

Usually works best: Fixed price Talk to us
“I used logistic regression, but my reviewer asked me to justify it and explain how it relates to my research model.”
KevinResearcher
How we help Justifying your statistical method

We walk you through how to present and justify your method so that it follows from your research question, design, outcome type and theoretical model.

Usually works best: Hourly mentoring Talk to us
“I have collected data from my study, but I'm not sure which statistical tests are best for my manuscript.”
JasonResearcher
How we help Choosing and running the right tests

We help you identify the tests that fit your research questions, your independent and dependent variables and the structure of your data, and run them with you on your own dataset.

Usually works best: Fixed price Talk to us

Scenarios are illustrative, based on requests we often receive from researchers.

Packages & pricing

Choose the support that fits your stage

We offer manuscript statistics support at three levels for quantitative and qualitative studies. Prices depend on your design, discipline and deadline, and every package starts with a free quote.

Prices for

Prices in USD, PhD level shown. Master's is 15% lower; postdoc and faculty 15% higher. Your exact price is confirmed in a free quote.

Basic

For straightforward studies that need descriptive and simple inferential results checked and reported.

From$149
Delivered in 5 to 7 working daysChoose Basic
  • Regression and multivariable models
  • Reporting guideline checklist
Recommended

Standard

For most journal manuscripts with group comparisons, regression or established qualitative approaches.

From$349
Delivered in 7 to 10 working daysChoose Standard
  • Everything in Basic
  • ANOVA, MANOVA, correlation and regression, or grounded theory and narrative analysis with NVivo support
  • Charts and journal-compliant tables
  • Guidance on drafting your Results
  • Reporting guideline checklist review
  • Structural equation and time-series models
  • Mixed-methods integration

Premium

For complex models, mixed-methods studies and manuscripts for demanding journals.

From$549
Delivered in 10 to 14 working daysChoose Premium
  • Everything in Standard
  • SEM, factor analysis or time-series analysis, or mixed-methods integration and triangulation
  • Custom figures
  • Formatting of statistical content to your target journal
  • Full review of the Methods and Results

Add-ons

Add any of these to a package, now or later. Your mentor stays the same.

See full pricing →
Our process

How it works, from order to final report

One single point of contact (SPOC) stays with you through every step, so you always know who to ask.

  1. 1Before we startSubmit your requirementsFill in the order form with your manuscript, target journal and requirements, then pay securely online so we can start right away.
  2. 2Day 1Confirmation and mentor matchYou receive an order confirmation, and we assign a statistician whose expertise matches your methods. A one-to-one call covers your study, timeline and deliverables.
  3. 3ThroughoutRegular updatesWe keep you informed of progress, and you can share new comments from co-authors, your supervisor or the journal at any point.
  4. 4While we workReview and guidanceYour mentor reviews your statistics, explains each suggested change and works with you on tables, figures and wording.
  5. 5ReviewRevisionsWe check the work against your original requirements and revise it in response to your feedback within the agreed scope.
  6. 6DeliveryFinal delivery and feedbackYou receive the final review and supporting files by email and through your client portal. We welcome your feedback.
Our guarantee

What we promise, we deliver

PhD Research Lab frames every manuscript statistical review to your target journal's author guidelines, the reporting guideline that fits your study design and your institution's research integrity policy. Our mentors have supported researchers at universities around the world, including the UK, the USA, the Netherlands, Australia, the UAE, Kenya, Nigeria, China and Russia. We never fabricate, alter or selectively report results: any re-analysis uses your own data and is done only with your approval, and every decision is documented so you can explain it to editors and reviewers.

Scholars we have supported study in
  • UK
  • USA
  • Netherlands
  • Germany
  • Ireland
  • Australia
  • UAE
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Qatar
  • Kenya
  • Nigeria
  • Russia
  • and more
  • Original workEvery document is checked for plagiarism before delivery.
  • On-time deliveryDelivered by the date we agree when you order.
  • Subject matter expertiseA mentor with doctoral-level knowledge of your field.
  • Talk to your mentorMessage your mentor directly through your single point of contact.
  • Ongoing supportQuestions answered at every step, before and after delivery.
  • Current academic sourcesBuilt on recent, peer-reviewed literature.
  • Research articles supplied*Copies of key articles used for your topics.
  • ConfidentialityYour details and work are never shared.

*Where access and copyright allow.

Scholar stories

Statistics a reviewer will accept

In their own words: scholars on working with PhD Assistance Research Lab.

I was unsure how strong my conclusions were. The reviewers validated my statistical interpretations and helped me improve how I explained my limitations, assumptions and implications. Their input improved my manuscript's scientific credibility a great deal.
Marta NovakEpidemiology PhD candidate, Poland
Quality and compliance

See how we keep every project on track

We have supported PhD projects for scholars around the world, and every task follows the same checks. These are real screens from our workflow.

Project brief checklist showing scope, university guidelines and deadline
Step 1 · Project brief Requirements confirmed in writing You share your requirements, university guidelines and deadline, and your point of contact confirms the scope with you before work starts.
Subject-matched mentor allocation for your project
Step 2 · Mentor allocation A subject-matched mentor is assigned Your project is assigned to a mentor who knows your subject and method, and you are introduced before the work begins.
Email thread between a scholar and our project coordinator
Step 3 · Regular updates Communication through email Updates, questions and changes from your supervisor go through your single point of contact, so you always have a written record.
Task record in our ERP system showing checklist items and quality-check status
Step 4 · Quality check Quality check in our ERP system Every task is tracked in our project system, with checklists and a manager's quality check before the work moves on.
Plagiarism report showing a 2% overall match
Step 5 · Plagiarism check Plagiarism report Each document goes through a similarity check before delivery, so you can submit it with confidence.
FAQs

Frequently asked questions

Ask a mentor
Can I talk to my statistician?

Yes. You can contact your mentor by email, video call or chat, and our project coordinator can schedule meetings when the project starts.

What does manuscript statistical review include?

Preliminary analysis (data cleaning, transformations, outlier and missing-data handling), primary analysis (variables, objectives, the smallest effect of practical importance and the results) and supplementary analysis (assumption checks, sensitivity and subgroup analyses), all reported in journal-ready tables and figures.

What statistical tests do you use?

The tests your design and data call for, including descriptive statistics; t-tests, ANOVA, ANCOVA, MANOVA and chi-square tests; non-parametric tests such as Mann-Whitney U, Wilcoxon and Kruskal-Wallis; Pearson, Spearman and Kendall correlation; linear, logistic and multilevel regression; exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis and SEM; time series and survival analysis; meta-analysis; and Bayesian methods.

Will you change my results?

No. We never fabricate, alter or selectively report data or results. If an analysis needs to be corrected or re-run, we explain why, do it only with your own data and approval, and document every change.

Can you guarantee my paper will be accepted?

No. Acceptance is decided by editors and reviewers. A careful statistical review removes avoidable errors and makes your results easier to assess.

Do you provide support with reviewer comments on statistics?

Yes. If reviewers commented on your statistical analysis, we can help you revise, re-analyse (with your data and approval) and reformat the statistical sections, and draft responses for you to review.

Should I acknowledge statistical support?

Yes. Journals that follow ICMJE recommendations expect contributors who do not meet authorship criteria, including statistical advisers, to be acknowledged. Your mentor can suggest wording.

How is pricing set?

Prices depend on your design, discipline and deadline. Our project coordinators can tell you about current seasonal discounts and referral offers.

Do you charge extra for revisions?

Revisions within the agreed scope of your package are included, including changes requested by your university or journal. Please read our terms and conditions when you place an order.