Responding to Reviewers · Module 03 of 05

Writing the point-by-point response letter

This module covers opening with a short cover summary, quoting each comment before answering it directly, and pointing to exact page and line numbers for every change. A clear, well-organised response letter is often what decides whether a revision is accepted.

Watch the first lesson of every module free. The remaining lessons, exercises and live sessions open when you enrol.

What you will be able to do

  • Open a response letter with a short summary of what changed
  • Quote each comment and then answer it directly
  • Reference exact page and line numbers for every change
  • Keep a respectful, professional tone throughout, including where you disagree

Key terms

  • Point-by-point response
  • Cover letter
  • Line reference
  • Professional tone

Hands-on practice

Draft the response to five of your own reviewer comments, each quoted in full, answered directly and pointing to the exact revised text.

Common pitfalls this module fixes

  • Answering comments vaguely, such as 'we have addressed this'; state exactly what changed and where.
  • Writing a defensive or irritated tone; thank the reviewer for the point even when declining to make the change, and explain why.