The five stages, adapted for Malaysia
Table 1 shows the main risk at each stage for an engineering PhD in Malaysia and the decision to make before moving on.
| Stage | Main risk | Decision to make before moving on |
|---|---|---|
| Proposal | Industry data is assumed in the research plan but has not been secured | Agree the scope of data access in writing; identify a fallback data source |
| Approvals | Collection begins before ethics and data protection requirements are confirmed | Obtain ethics committee approval; check PDPA obligations, including cross-border transfer of data |
| Pilot | Instruments, rigs or questionnaires fail under real conditions | Run a small-scale trial in the actual environment; calibrate and log ambient temperature, humidity and rainfall |
| Main data collection | Too few responses, or gaps in field and test data | Recruit through several channels and registration grades; check response numbers and data completeness weekly |
| Data management and write-up | Results cannot be traced to raw data or lack stated uncertainty | Keep FAIR-aligned records; report measurement uncertainty; version-control analysis scripts |
What to settle at each stage in Malaysia
Proposal: getting data from industry and government
Much engineering research in Malaysia relies on data from industry and public-sector partners, such as operating records from oil, gas and petrochemical facilities, generation and network data from power utilities, process data from electrical and electronics manufacturing, or design and monitoring data from construction and infrastructure projects.
Where the data belongs to a federal or state government agency, the Official Secrets Act 1972 and government circulars govern how it is handled (Rödl & Partner, 2024), so a researcher should expect questions about classification and clearance as well as commercial confidentiality. Agree the data scope in writing at the proposal stage, including how classified or confidential fields will be handled, and name a fallback such as a public dataset, simulation or laboratory-scale experiment.
Approvals: university ethics committees and the amended PDPA
In Malaysia, ethics review for engineering studies with human participants sits mainly with university committees, guided by the Malaysian Code of Responsible Conduct in Research (National Science Council, 2020). Procedures differ between institutions.
At the University of Malaya, for example, the non-medical research ethics committee reviews all non-medical research involving human participants, and researchers must not approach or recruit participants, or collect data for any purpose including a pilot study, before approval is given; studies that use only secondary data follow a separate exemption process (University of Malaya Research Ethics Committee – Non-Medical, n.d.). Research that involves the subjects or facilities of the Ministry of Health must instead be approved by the Medical Research and Ethics Committee (UiTM Research Ethics Committee, 2025), which can matter for engineering topics such as hospital building services or medical devices.
The Personal Data Protection Act 2010 (PDPA), which took effect on 15 November 2013, governs personal data processed in commercial transactions (Lex Mundi, n.d.; Tay & Partners, 2024). It does not apply to the Federal Government and State Governments, so data held by government departments falls outside it, although other rules such as the Official Secrets Act 1972 still bind public officers (Rödl & Partner, 2024).
The Personal Data Protection (Amendment) Act 2024 came into force in phases between January and June 2025. It introduced mandatory data protection officers, mandatory breach notification and a right to data portability, and it extended the definition of sensitive personal data to include biometric data (ASEAN Briefing, 2025; Mayer Brown, 2025; Rödl & Partner, 2024). Notification to the Commissioner is required where a breach is likely to cause or has caused significant harm, or is of significant scale, and is expected within 72 hours of the data controller becoming aware of it (ASEAN Briefing, 2025; Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer, 2024). Whether the Act reaches a particular study depends on whether the data is processed in a commercial transaction and identifies an individual, so a researcher who receives personnel, vehicle telematics or smart-building records from a company partner should assume that the partner is bound by it, and should confirm the university’s own position with its data protection officer.
The Act also restricts transfers of personal data outside Malaysia. The former whitelist of approved countries has been removed, and transfers now rely on conditions such as the destination having a substantially similar law or an adequate level of protection, as set out in the Cross Border Personal Data Transfer Guidelines issued on 29 April 2025 (Mayer Brown, 2025). Researchers who plan to store data on overseas cloud services or share it with co-supervisors abroad should settle the legal basis with their institution at this stage rather than after data collection has begun.
Pilot: humidity, rain and haze
Malaysian field conditions test instruments differently from arid regions. The climate is hot and tropical with uneven rainfall through the year, low wind speeds, and relative humidity reported at 80–90% in the rainy season and about 47% in the dry season, and the dust that settles on exposed surfaces tends to be wet (Islam et al., 2022). In a 12-month study of a 2.5 MW photovoltaic site in Terengganu, power loss from soiling averaged 26.22%, with losses ranging from 4.86% to 58.67% over the period (Jamil et al., 2020, as reported by Islam et al., 2022). Haze episodes, such as the 2013 Southeast Asian haze, have also been evaluated for their effect on solar generation (Maghami et al., 2015).
Humidity, rainfall and dust can affect pyranometers, anemometers, strain gauges, air-quality sensors and logger enclosures through condensation, moisture ingress, corrosion and fouling. A short pilot in the actual deployment environment, with calibration checks before and after, a record of cleaning and maintenance events, and ambient temperature, humidity, rainfall and dust logged alongside the main variables, shows whether the planned sampling interval, sensor placement and maintenance schedule are realistic. Where the main campaign will span both wet and dry conditions, the pilot should if possible include a rainy period. Survey pilots should test the Bahasa Malaysia version as well as the English one.
Main collection: a register dominated by graduate engineers
Research that surveys or interviews engineers in Malaysia must account for how the profession is structured. Registration with the Board of Engineers Malaysia (BEM) is a legal prerequisite for practising as an engineer, yet as of 31 July 2025 the register held 219,268 Graduate Engineers and only 18,130 Professional Engineers, including those with practising certificates, or about 7% of a register of more than 262,000 that also includes engineering technologists and inspectors of works (Wan Harun, 2025). A sample recruited only through professional bodies or senior contacts may therefore over-represent the small group of Professional Engineers, and some graduates perform engineering roles without registering at all (Wan Harun, 2025).
Responses may also differ by career stage, by sector, and between Peninsular Malaysia, Sabah and Sarawak. To balance the sample, recruit through several routes, such as engineering firms, project sites, university alumni networks and the Institution of Engineers Malaysia, since each reaches different grades.
Write-up: protecting personal and restricted data
Malaysia adds two points to the usual rules for traceable data, which are the FAIR principles, a stated measurement uncertainty and version-controlled analysis scripts (Wilkinson et al., 2016; Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology [JCGM], 2008). First, where the data includes personal information, the PDPA’s security and retention principles mean the thesis should record how raw files are protected and when they will be deleted. Second, where a government or industry partner’s data is restricted, explain what was anonymised or aggregated so that examiners can judge the analysis without seeing the restricted values.
Conclusion
For engineering researchers in Malaysia, the stages are the same as anywhere, but the decisions are not. Secure written access from industry and government partners early, settle ethics approval and PDPA duties (including cross-border transfers) before contacting anyone, pilot instruments through a rainy period, recruit across registration grades, languages and regions, and record how personal and restricted data is protected.
What to do now
- List every partner whose data you need and whether it is government or industry data.
- Ask your university ethics committee which approval route applies, and whether MREC approval is needed.
- Check with your data protection officer how the PDPA affects storage and overseas transfer.
- Plan a field pilot that covers at least one rainy period.
- Set recruitment targets by registration grade, language and region.
Frequently asked questions
Does the PDPA apply to PhD research data in Malaysia?
It applies to personal data processed in commercial transactions, so it usually binds industry partners. Confirm your university’s own position with its data protection officer.
Can I store Malaysian research data on overseas cloud services?
Only on a lawful basis under the amended PDPA and the 2025 Cross Border Personal Data Transfer Guidelines. Settle this with your institution before collection.
Do engineering surveys in Malaysia need ethics approval?
Yes, if they involve human participants. University committees review non-medical research; Ministry of Health settings need MREC approval.
Related reading: PhD support in Malaysia · Engineering PhD data collection in Saudi Arabia · Who owns your PhD data? A data passport for US engineering researchers
Key takeaways
- Data access: government data falls under the Official Secrets Act 1972, so expect classification questions as well as commercial ones.
- Ethics: university committees review non-medical research; Ministry of Health settings need MREC approval.
- PDPA: the 2024 amendments added mandatory breach notification, data protection officers and new cross-border transfer rules.
- Pilot: humidity, rain and haze affect sensors; pilot through a rainy period if you can.
- Sampling: about 7% of registered engineers are Professional Engineers, so recruit across grades.
