Who this list is for
This list is for doctoral and master's researchers interested in how visual art is taught and learned in schools, colleges and universities. The topics fall into three themes: studio teaching and theory, digital and inclusive teaching, and what art education does for thinking and feeling.
How to use this list
Treat each row as a starting point. Decide your setting (secondary school, art college or university), the learners you can reach and whether you are also the teacher. Many art educators research their own practice; that is a legitimate design, with its own rules on rigour and ethics (Cochran-Smith & Lytle, 2009). If you are still choosing a broad area, start with how to choose a PhD topic and how to select a PhD topic. Related lists: education, design and cultural studies.
Theme 1: Studio teaching, learning spaces and theory
Studio teaching is the core of visual art education, yet how teacher-led instruction, independent making and critique are balanced varies widely, as does the link between studio work and art theory. These questions suit classroom case studies and action research, in which a teacher plans a change, observes it and refines it over cycles (Mills, 2018).
| Topic | Possible research question | Likely design and data | Why it matters now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balancing teacher-led and student-led studio teaching | How does shifting the balance between demonstration and student-led inquiry in a studio course change students' engagement and the quality of their portfolios? | Action research over two or three teaching cycles; observation, student work, interviews | Studio practice varies widely, and change is best studied in the setting where it happens (Mills, 2018) |
| Connecting art theory and studio practice | Where do students see links, or gaps, between theory modules and studio work, and which teaching strategies help them use theory in making? | Multiple case study in two programmes; document analysis of curricula, student interviews, reflective journals | Programmes still often teach theory and practice separately, which students report as a divide |
Theme 2: Digital and inclusive art education
Hybrid and online teaching raised a practical question for art: how do you teach hands-on making at a distance? A second question concerns whose art and culture the curriculum represents. Inclusive approaches that bring students' voices into teaching decisions offer one tested route (Messiou & Ainscow, 2020).
| Topic | Possible research question | Likely design and data | Why it matters now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hybrid studio teaching in tertiary art education | Which parts of studio learning do teachers and students find work in hybrid formats, and which need in-person contact? | Mixed methods: survey of staff and students, then case studies of two hybrid courses | Hybrid formats introduced in recent years are now being kept or dropped, often without evidence |
| Culturally responsive pedagogy in visual art classrooms | How far does a visual art curriculum draw on students' cultural backgrounds, and how does a culturally responsive unit change their engagement? | Curriculum audit, then a design-based study of one unit with student-teacher dialogue and observation | Student voice approaches can make classrooms more inclusive (Messiou & Ainscow, 2020) |
Theme 3: Critical thinking and social-emotional learning
Claims that art education builds critical thinking, empathy or emotional skills are common. The most thorough international review found clear causal evidence mainly for verbal skills from theatre and music education; evidence on creativity, empathy and other social and emotional outcomes was limited, largely correlational and described as tentative (Winner et al., 2013). The authors stress that a lack of evidence is not evidence of no effect. That gap is a doctoral opportunity, provided outcomes are measured well. Use validated instruments or design and pilot your own carefully (Artino et al., 2014).
| Topic | Possible research question | Likely design and data | Why it matters now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Critique-based teaching and interpretive reasoning in secondary art | Do students taught with structured critique and visual analysis show stronger interpretive reasoning about artworks than comparable students taught mainly technical skills? | Quasi-experimental comparison of classes; rubric-scored written and oral responses; teacher interviews | Evidence for thinking skills from visual art is limited (Winner et al., 2013) |
| Visual art education and social-emotional outcomes | Does a term-long studio programme change students' emotion regulation or empathy, measured with validated scales, and how do students describe the change? | Mixed methods: pre and post measures with a comparison group; interviews with a subsample | Effects on empathy and related skills are plausible but tentative (Winner et al., 2013) |
How to test a topic before you commit
Run each candidate through the FINER criteria: is it feasible, interesting, novel, ethical and relevant (Hulley et al., 2013)? Ask, too, whether the question challenges an assumption in the field, such as the belief that art automatically develops thinking skills, rather than only filling a gap (Alvesson & Sandberg, 2011).
- Access: secure agreement from a school or programme before you build the topic around it.
- Ethics: research with children needs parental consent and school approval; plan for this early.
- Dual role: if you teach the class you study, explain how you will limit bias and pressure on students.
- Measurement: decide how you will judge quality of art work or thinking before you collect data.
Worked example (illustrative)
A secondary art teacher begins with "art and emotional intelligence". The FINER check shows the idea is interesting but too broad, and "emotional intelligence" has several competing definitions. She chooses one outcome, empathy, finds a validated adolescent scale, and arranges for two parallel classes in her school to take part, one following a new portrait and narrative unit and one following the usual curriculum. Her question becomes: "Does a ten-week portrait and narrative unit change Year 9 students' empathy scores, and how do students describe what they learned?" The topic is now specific, measurable and ethical to run.
See also PhD topic selection, problem identification and gap identification.
Common mistakes
- Assuming the outcome you want to study, for example that art builds emotional intelligence.
- Bundling several studies (teaching method, learning space, lifelong learning) into one thesis.
- Using teachers' opinions as evidence that a method works.
- Measuring creativity or critical thinking with an unvalidated questionnaire written in a week.
- Overlooking safeguarding and consent when working with school pupils.
Key takeaways
- Visual art education offers live doctoral questions in studio teaching, digital and inclusive practice, and learning outcomes.
- Evidence that visual art builds critical thinking or empathy is limited and largely correlational, so these remain open questions (Winner et al., 2013).
- Practitioner and action research are legitimate designs when planned with rigour (Cochran-Smith & Lytle, 2009; Mills, 2018).
- Good measurement decides whether an outcome study is credible (Artino et al., 2014).
- Test every topic for feasibility, novelty, ethics and relevance before you commit (Hulley et al., 2013).
