Literature Review & Synthesis · Module 03 of 06

Critical appraisal of sources

This module covers assessing the methodological quality of a source, distinguishing description from critique, and weighing evidence by study design, sample and rigour. Critical appraisal is what separates a review from an annotated bibliography.

Watch the first lesson of every module free. The remaining lessons, exercises and live sessions open when you enrol.

What you will be able to do

  • Assess the methodological quality of a quantitative or qualitative source
  • Distinguish describing a source from critiquing it
  • Weigh evidence by study design, sample and rigour
  • Note limitations that affect how much weight a source should carry

Key terms

  • Critical appraisal
  • Methodological quality
  • Evidence weighting
  • Limitations

Hands-on practice

Write a short critical appraisal paragraph for each of five key sources in your review, noting strengths and limitations.

Common pitfalls this module fixes

  • Treating every source as equally authoritative; weigh claims by design, sample and rigour.
  • Writing appraisal as a list of adjectives such as 'limited' or 'weak' without saying why.