About this example
This page is a doctoral research proposal in education, written at the level expected for a PhD or professional doctorate (EdD) application or a confirmation review. It proposes a qualitative, design-based study of virtual instructor-led training (VILT): live online sessions, run by a trainer, that aim to develop adults' soft skills such as communication, feedback and leadership.
It is an illustrative teaching example, not a real student's work, and any organisation or participant details are anonymised or invented for teaching. The grey "What to notice" notes explain what each passage does and why.
Use it to see how the parts of a proposal connect: how the problem leads to the questions, and how the questions decide the design, sample and analysis. Then build your own argument from your own reading. Do not submit any part of it as your own work; your university's academic integrity rules apply.
For the wider method, read the research proposal guide, writing the literature review for a proposal and choosing a dissertation methodology. More examples are in the sample work library.
The example: background and problem
Background
Organisations have moved a large share of staff development from the classroom to live online sessions, a shift accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic and sustained since by cost, reach and hybrid working. Soft-skills programmes are a demanding case for this move, because they depend on practice, observation and feedback that classroom trainers have traditionally delivered face to face. Whether live online formats can support that kind of learning for adults, and under what design conditions, is therefore a practical question for training providers as well as a theoretical one for adult education.
Andragogy offers one lens on that question. In the tradition developed by Knowles, adult learning is described through a set of assumptions: adults need to know why they are learning, see themselves as self-directing, bring experience that is a resource for learning, become ready to learn when tasks matter to their lives, prefer problem-centred learning and are motivated mainly from within (Knowles et al., 2020). These are working assumptions for design rather than a tested causal theory, which is why this proposal treats them as sensitising ideas to examine, not hypotheses to confirm.
Research problem
Training providers can now choose from many platform features (breakout rooms, polls, shared whiteboards, recorded role-play) and many facilitation strategies, yet there is little guidance on which combinations help adults practise and transfer soft skills in live online sessions. Evaluation in this setting often stops at end-of-session satisfaction scores, which say little about how learners experience practice and feedback or how trainers adapt their designs. The problem this study addresses is the lack of design principles for VILT soft-skills programmes that are grounded in the experiences of both adult learners and the trainers who design and run the sessions.
The example: aims, questions and literature
Aim and research questions
The aim of the study is to develop and refine design principles for live online soft-skills training for adults, informed by andragogy and by the experiences of learners and trainers. The central question is: how do adult learners and trainers experience virtual instructor-led soft-skills training, and what design features do they see as supporting or hindering learning? Four sub-questions follow.
- Which platform features and facilitation strategies do trainers use to support practice and feedback in VILT soft-skills sessions, and why?
- Which learning activities do adult learners describe as helping or hindering their development of soft skills, and how do these relate to andragogical assumptions?
- How do trainers adapt session design between iterations in response to learner experience?
- Which design principles, judged by participants as feasible and worth the effort, can be proposed for future VILT soft-skills programmes?
Literature to be reviewed
The full proposal will review three bodies of work. The first is adult learning theory, starting with the andragogical model and its critiques, so that the study can say which assumptions it examines (Knowles et al., 2020). The second is research on online and technology-enhanced learning environments, including design-based studies of how such environments are built and improved (Wang & Hannafin, 2005), and recent accounts of online learning for working adults, such as work-integrated online activities with doctoral students (Areskoug Josefsson, 2025). The third is research on soft-skills development and transfer in workplace training.
The review will be conducted as a documented search (databases, search strings, date range and inclusion criteria recorded in an appendix) so that the gap stated in the problem can be shown rather than asserted. Sources older than about ten years will be used for theory and method, with recent empirical studies used to describe current practice.
The example: method and ethics
Research design and philosophy
The study uses design-based research, an approach in which researchers and practitioners work together through iterative cycles of analysis, design, enactment and revision in a real setting, producing both an improved intervention and context-sensitive design principles (Wang & Hannafin, 2005). It fits the aim because the goal is not to test one fixed course but to improve a programme and explain why the changes work. The study is framed by constructionism, the epistemological position that meaning is constructed by people in interaction with their world (Crotty, 1998); learners' and trainers' accounts are therefore treated as interpretations to be understood, not as neutral reports of effectiveness.
Setting, participants and data
The setting is a soft-skills programme delivered through live online sessions by a training provider that agrees to take part. Two design cycles are planned. In each cycle, data will come from semi-structured interviews with adult learners and with trainers, observation notes from recorded sessions (with consent), and design documents such as session plans. Participants will be selected purposively to include different roles, levels of experience and familiarity with online learning. Instead of fixing the number in advance, sample adequacy will be judged by information power, which depends on the study's aim, the specificity of the sample, the use of theory, the quality of dialogue and the analysis strategy (Malterud et al., 2016); the indicative plan of 10 to 15 learners, together with the trainers who design and deliver the sessions, will be reviewed after the first cycle.
Analysis and quality
Interview transcripts and observation notes will be analysed with reflexive thematic analysis: familiarisation, coding, generating initial themes, reviewing and defining themes, and writing up (Braun & Clarke, 2006). The analysis treats the researcher's interpretation as part of the method, so a reflexive journal will be kept and coding decisions recorded (Braun & Clarke, 2021). Themes from cycle one will inform the redesign for cycle two, and the final analysis will relate themes to the andragogical assumptions and to draft design principles. Trustworthiness will be addressed through credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability (Lincoln & Guba, 1985), using an audit trail and thick description as practical strategies (Nowell et al., 2017), and the study will be judged against recognised markers of qualitative quality such as sincerity, credibility and meaningful coherence (Tracy, 2010).
Ethics
Approval will be sought from the university research ethics committee before any data collection, and the training provider's written permission will be obtained. Participants will receive an information sheet, give written informed consent, and may withdraw without consequence; session recordings will be made only with the consent of everyone present. Because the researcher also works as a trainer, they will not interview learners from their own courses, and recruitment will be handled by a programme administrator so that no learner feels obliged to take part. Data will be pseudonymised and stored on university systems in line with data protection law. Ethics is also treated as ongoing, with attention to the "ethically important moments" that arise during interviews, such as a participant disclosing workplace conflict (Guillemin & Gillam, 2004).
The example: timeline and expected contribution
Timeline
| Period (full-time) | Main activities | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Months 1 to 9 | Systematic search and literature review; ethics application; agreement with training provider | Literature review chapter draft; ethics approval |
| Months 10 to 18 | Design cycle 1: baseline observation, interviews, first analysis, redesign with trainers | Cycle 1 findings and revised session design |
| Months 19 to 27 | Design cycle 2: enactment of revised design, interviews, analysis | Cycle 2 findings; draft design principles |
| Months 28 to 36 | Integration, writing, member reflections with participants, submission | Thesis and one journal article draft |
Expected contribution
The study is expected to contribute in three ways. Theoretically, it will show which andragogical assumptions are visible, strained or reshaped in live online soft-skills training. Methodologically, it will provide a worked account of design-based research applied to workplace training rather than formal education, reported in enough detail for others to judge and reuse (Wang & Hannafin, 2005; Creswell & Guetterman, 2024). Practically, it will offer trainers a small set of design principles, each linked to evidence from the two cycles, that other providers can test in their own settings.
How to adapt this to your own study
- Write your problem in one paragraph: who is affected, what is missing, and why it matters now. Check it against a documented search before claiming a gap.
- Decide what kind of answer you need (description, explanation, improvement, test) and choose the design that produces it; do not combine designs because each sounds rigorous.
- Write research questions your data can actually answer, and map each question to a data source in a simple table.
- Justify your sample with an argument from the methods literature, for example information power for interviews (Malterud et al., 2016), and plan when you will review it.
- Name one analysis procedure, cite it, and describe what you will do at each step.
- Identify the main ethical risk in your setting (power, confidentiality, recordings, vulnerable participants) and the safeguard for each.
- Draft a timeline that puts ethics approval before fieldwork and leaves at least a quarter of the time for analysis and writing.
Common mistakes in this chapter
- Listing theorists one after another instead of explaining the one framework the study uses.
- Claiming "no research exists" without a search to show it.
- Mixing philosophical terms (constructionism, constructivism, interpretivism) without defining the one you adopt.
- Naming several designs (grounded theory, design-based research, phenomenology) in one proposal with no rationale.
- Asking questions the data cannot answer, such as cost-effectiveness from interviews alone.
- Treating ethics as a list of promises rather than identifying specific risks and safeguards.
- Leaving malformed or unverifiable references in the list.
| What examiners look for | Where this example does it | Check in your own draft |
|---|---|---|
| A clear, evidenced problem | Research problem paragraph; documented search plan | Can you show the gap, not just assert it? |
| Questions aligned to the aim | Central question and four sub-questions | Does each question map to a data source? |
| A coherent design and philosophy | Design-based research in a constructionist frame | Is there one chain from philosophy to analysis? |
| A justified sample | Information power argument | Have you explained why your number is adequate? |
| A named, citable analysis | Reflexive thematic analysis with quality strategies | Could another researcher follow your steps? |
| Specific ethical safeguards | Insider risk handled through third-party recruitment | Have you named your main risk and its safeguard? |
| A feasible plan | Timeline table across 36 months | Does fieldwork start after ethics approval? |
Key takeaways
- A proposal is persuasive when each section follows from the one before it, from problem to questions to design.
- Design-based research suits studies that aim to improve a programme and explain why the changes work (Wang & Hannafin, 2005).
- Andragogy is best used as a set of assumptions to examine in the data (Knowles et al., 2020).
- Justify interview numbers with information power and review them during fieldwork (Malterud et al., 2016).
- Name one analysis procedure and show how you will make your interpretation transparent (Braun & Clarke, 2021).
