What the 2018 regulations do
The University Grants Commission (Promotion of Academic Integrity and Prevention of Plagiarism in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations, 2018 were notified on 23 July 2018. They define academic integrity as intellectual honesty in proposing, performing and reporting any activity that leads to the creation of intellectual property, and define plagiarism as taking someone else's work or idea and passing it off as one's own (University Grants Commission, 2018).
The regulations do three things. They require institutions to build awareness of responsible research conduct, including research ethics content for master's students and research scholars. They require technology-based checks, declarations and supervisor certificates. And they set a graded scale of similarity levels and penalties, decided through departmental and institutional panels (University Grants Commission, 2018). The 2022 Ph.D. regulations build on this by making a no-plagiarism undertaking and an originality certificate part of every thesis submission (University Grants Commission, 2022).
How similarity levels and exclusions work
Before any percentage is calculated, certain material is excluded: quotations reproduced with permission or attribution, references and bibliography, the table of contents, preface and acknowledgements, and generic terms, laws, standard symbols and standard equations (University Grants Commission, 2018). Common knowledge and coincidental strings of up to fourteen consecutive words are also excluded.
The regulations add an important note: research must rest on original ideas in the abstract, summary, hypothesis, observations, results, conclusions and recommendations (University Grants Commission, 2018). A low overall percentage therefore does not protect copied results or conclusions, and a panel looks at what was copied, not only how much.
| Level | Similarity | Consequence for a student's thesis |
|---|---|---|
| Level 0 | Up to 10% | Minor similarity, no penalty |
| Level 1 | Above 10% to 40% | Submit a revised script within a period not exceeding six months |
| Level 2 | Above 40% to 60% | Debarred from submitting a revised script for one year |
| Level 3 | Above 60% | Registration for the programme cancelled |
Repeated plagiarism attracts the penalty one level above the previous offence, and benefits or credits already awarded can be suspended while a case is decided (University Grants Commission, 2018).
How cases are decided, and self-plagiarism
Complaints go first to a Departmental Academic Integrity Panel, chaired by the head of department with an external senior academician and a person familiar with anti-plagiarism tools. It reports within 45 days to the Institutional Academic Integrity Panel, which also has 45 days to make its recommendation (University Grants Commission, 2018). Penalties may be imposed only after misconduct has been established without doubt, appeals have been exhausted and the person has had a fair and transparent opportunity to defend themselves.
Reusing your own earlier text is also a concern. In April 2020 UGC asked vice chancellors and selection committees to check for text recycling, or "self-plagiarism", including republishing earlier work and splitting one study into several papers without acknowledgement (University Grants Commission, 2020a). Its guidance on good academic research practices treats fabrication, falsification and plagiarism as research misconduct (University Grants Commission, 2020b).
