The source and why it matters
The paper under review is Ganesha and Aithal (2022), "Why is it called Doctor of Philosophy and why choosing appropriate research philosophical paradigm is indispensable during Ph.D. program in India?", published in the first volume of the International Journal of Philosophy and Languages and widely read as a preprint on SSRN. It addresses a real problem. Many doctoral researchers meet the vocabulary of ontology, epistemology and paradigms late, often when writing the methodology chapter, and struggle to connect it to the choices they have already made. The paper argues that the "philosophy" in Doctor of Philosophy should be taken seriously and offers a model, which it calls CRPhP, for choosing a paradigm.
The argument that philosophy is central to the PhD is not new. Baldwin (2014) argued that the word "philosophy" in the title implies a greater emphasis on philosophical positioning than in professional doctorates, and that a candidate's philosophical position drives both the questions a study asks and the methods it uses. The value of the paper under review therefore lies less in the argument than in the practical model it offers, which is what this review examines.

What the paper proposes
The paper treats a paradigm as a basic set of beliefs, or worldview, that guides an investigation, made up of assumptions about the nature of reality (ontology), about how it can be known (epistemology) and about the role of values (axiology). It gives seven reasons why a paradigm matters to a doctoral study: clarity, guidance on methodology, validity, interdisciplinary work, epistemological awareness, a sense of belonging to a research community, and adaptability.
The model then proposes criteria for choosing a paradigm: the best fit to the research question, the end use of the research, its end users, the demand created by the research gap, the paradigm common in the field, and the Ph.D. scholar's own philosophy. Its most distinctive recommendation is a sequence in which a doctoral programme moves through several paradigms in turn, as shown in Figure 2.
- 1Phase 1: interpretivism (explore and build a model)
- 2Phase 2: positivism (test the model)
- 3Phase 3: critical realism (explain mechanisms)
- 4Phase 4: pragmatism (apply and solve problems)
- 5Phase 5: critical theory (expose power relations)
Strengths
- It makes the implicit explicit. Asking scholars to name their assumptions early is sound advice, and mainstream methods texts make the same point (Creswell & Creswell, 2023; Saunders et al., 2023).
- It ties the paradigm to the question. "Best fit to the research question" is the right first criterion, and it guards against choosing a paradigm by habit.
- It thinks about use and users. Asking who will use the findings links philosophy to the purpose of the research, which is often missing from methodology chapters.
- It recognises plurality. By naming five paradigms the model avoids presenting positivism and interpretivism as the only options.
Limitations and methodological issues
The sequential-paradigm claim
The recommendation to move through five paradigms in sequence is the model's weakest point. Paradigms are not stages of a project; they rest on different and sometimes incompatible assumptions about reality and knowledge. A study that treats findings as socially constructed in one phase and as observer-independent facts in the next must explain how the two are reconciled, and the paper does not. Where researchers do combine qualitative and quantitative work, the usual justification is a single stance, often pragmatism, together with an explicit plan for integrating the strands (Creswell & Creswell, 2023; Fetters et al., 2013). Five paradigms are also hard to fit into one doctorate, and the sequence is not tested on any actual programmes.
An unsourced completion figure and a weak inference
The earlier summary of the paper stated that only about half of PhD scholars complete within ten years and presented this as evidence of a lack of awareness of the philosophy in the PhD. No source was given, and the inference does not follow. Completion depends on many factors, including supervision, funding, socialisation into the discipline and well-being (Sverdlik et al., 2018); no evidence is offered that paradigm awareness is among the causes. A figure like this must be sourced, dated and limited to the country and field it describes.
Criteria that can pull against each other
Choosing the paradigm "common in the field" can conflict with choosing the one that best fits the question, and the model gives no rule for resolving such conflicts. "Demand" and "end users" are not defined precisely enough to apply. Nor does the model say how a scholar's own philosophy should be identified.
The venue
The paper appeared in the first volume of a new journal, and the copy most readers find is a preprint. Neither fact says anything about quality in itself, but both mean a reader should check the journal's indexing, editorial board and peer review policy before relying on it. Hijacked and low-quality journals are a growing problem for early-career researchers (Abalkina, 2025; Retraction Watch, 2025), and the same checks apply to any source cited in a methodology chapter.
How the paper sits in the wider literature
The paradigm debate has a long history. The naturalistic paradigm was set out against conventional positivist inquiry in the 1980s (Lincoln & Guba, 1985), and later work added a participatory paradigm (Heron & Reason, 1997) and a transformative paradigm centred on social justice (Mertens, 2007). Methods texts now present paradigms as worldviews that shape, but do not dictate, design choices (Creswell & Creswell, 2023; Creswell & Poth, 2018), and business methods texts frame the choice as a layered decision from philosophy to techniques (Saunders et al., 2023). Compared with these, the CRPhP model is more prescriptive. Its criteria are a useful checklist, but its sequence runs against the mainstream view that one coherent stance should run through a thesis.
| Paradigm | View of reality | View of knowledge | Typical approaches | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Positivism | One reality, independent of the observer | Objective measurement and testing | Experiments, surveys, statistical models | Testing hypotheses about measurable relationships |
| Interpretivism | Multiple, socially constructed realities | Understanding meanings in context | Interviews, ethnography, case studies | Exploring experiences and meanings |
| Critical realism | Real structures that are only partly observable | Fallible explanation of mechanisms | Mixed and case-based designs | Explaining why outcomes occur |
| Pragmatism | Reality judged by practical consequences | What works to answer the question | Mixed methods | Problem-centred and applied questions |
| Transformative or critical | Realities shaped by power and values | Knowledge aimed at change | Participatory and emancipatory designs | Research on inequality and voice |
What it means for doctoral researchers
Use the paper's criteria as prompts, not as a procedure. Start from the research question, state the assumptions it carries, and choose one stance that you can defend throughout the thesis. If you combine methods, justify the combination with a single stance and explain how the strands will be integrated.
Worked example (illustrative). A scholar wants to know whether a mentoring scheme reduces early-career teacher attrition and how teachers experience it. A five-phase sequence would ask for separate interpretive, positivist, critical realist, pragmatic and critical phases. A defensible alternative is one pragmatic stance with a convergent mixed-methods design: a quantitative comparison of retention and interviews on experience, integrated in a joint display (Fetters et al., 2013). The thesis is coherent, achievable and still philosophically explicit.
In the methodology chapter, a short and explicit statement usually serves better than a long survey of every paradigm. Examiners look for consistency between what you say you believe about knowledge and what you actually do.
- State your research question and the kind of answer it seeks: a measured relationship, an understood experience, an explained mechanism or a practical solution.
- Name your stance and its assumptions about reality, knowledge and values in two or three sentences, citing a methods text (Creswell & Creswell, 2023).
- Show how the stance shaped your design, sampling, data and analysis.
- Explain the quality criteria that follow from it, for example validity and reliability or credibility and transferability (Lincoln & Guba, 1985).
- Acknowledge what the stance cannot show, and how you have limited your claims accordingly.
Common mistakes with research paradigms
- Naming a paradigm in the methodology chapter that the rest of the thesis does not follow.
- Choosing a paradigm because it is common in the department rather than because it fits the question.
- Listing several paradigms without explaining how their assumptions are reconciled.
- Treating "mixed methods" as a paradigm rather than a design that still needs a stance.
- Citing statistics about doctoral completion without a source, date or context.
- Relying on a model or framework from a single source without checking how it has been received and tested.
Key takeaways
- The paper rightly asks scholars to make their philosophical assumptions explicit (Ganesha & Aithal, 2022).
- Its five-paradigm sequence is untested and conflicts with the need for one coherent stance (Creswell & Creswell, 2023).
- Combining methods needs a stance and a plan for integration (Fetters et al., 2013).
- Doctoral completion depends on many factors; unsourced figures should not carry an argument (Sverdlik et al., 2018).
- Check the venue and indexing of any source before relying on it (Abalkina, 2025).
