What COPE is and what it maintains
COPE, the Committee on Publication Ethics, is a membership organisation of journal editors, publishers and research institutions that provides guidance on handling publication ethics issues. Its central practical document is its Core Practices, a set of expectations for editors and publishers introduced in 2017, which replaced an earlier, more detailed 2004 Code of Conduct for Editors.
The Core Practices cover areas such as handling allegations of misconduct, authorship disputes, conflicts of interest, data and reproducibility, ethical oversight of research involving people or animals, intellectual property, post-publication discussion and corrections, and complaints. Alongside the Core Practices, COPE publishes detailed flowcharts that set out, step by step, how an editor should handle specific situations, such as a suspicion of plagiarism discovered after publication, or a reviewer who suspects undisclosed duplicate submission.
The flowcharts are deliberately procedural rather than judgemental: each one walks an editor through who to contact, what to ask, and what evidence to gather before any decision is made, rather than instructing the editor to assume wrongdoing from the outset. This matters because many publication ethics concerns turn out to have an innocent explanation, such as a genuine misunderstanding about what had already been disclosed, and a fair process needs to allow for that outcome as readily as a more serious one.
Why it exists
Before COPE, individual editors faced publication ethics problems, such as a suspicion of data fabrication or a dispute between co-authors over author order, without a shared reference point for how such cases should be handled fairly and consistently. Handling similar cases inconsistently between journals undermines trust in the process and can be unfair to the researchers involved on either side of a dispute.
COPE exists to give editors a shared, tested set of expectations and step-by-step flowcharts, so that a given type of concern, whichever journal it arises at, is handled through a broadly similar, fair process rather than being improvised each time by whoever happens to be the editor that week.
There is also a protective function in this for researchers who are, in good faith, on the receiving end of a concern. A documented, consistent process gives an author facing a query the chance to respond and provide evidence before any conclusion is reached, rather than facing an ad hoc judgement made without a clear procedure.
Which situations it covers
COPE guidance is written for editors and publishers, but a doctoral researcher benefits from understanding it because it describes, in detail, what will happen procedurally if a concern is raised about their own manuscript, and because several of its flowcharts describe problems that are genuinely easy to fall into without intending any wrongdoing.
- Submitting very similar findings, or the same dataset, to more than one journal without disclosure: covered by COPE's duplicate and redundant publication guidance.
- A disagreement between a student and supervisor, or between collaborators, over who should be an author or in what order: covered by COPE's authorship dispute guidance, usually read alongside the ICMJE authorship criteria.
- Reusing figures, data or substantial text from your own earlier publication without citing it: covered by COPE's guidance on text recycling and image integrity.
- A reviewer or reader raising a concern about a published paper's data or conclusions after publication: covered by COPE's post-publication and correction guidance.
Where COPE does not reach
COPE does not itself investigate a specific case; that responsibility sits with the journal, and where the allegation concerns the conduct of the research itself rather than only the manuscript, with the researcher's own institution. COPE's role is to provide the framework and process guidance editors and institutions use, and, for member journals, a point of advice when a case is genuinely difficult, not to adjudicate the facts of a dispute itself.
COPE guidance also does not set the authorship criteria themselves, which are the ICMJE Recommendations' responsibility (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, 2024), nor does it set the detailed role expectations for industry-sponsored publications, which the GPP 2022 guidelines cover (DeTora et al., 2022). COPE sits alongside both, providing the process for handling a concern once one is raised, rather than the substantive rules those other guidelines set out.
Nor does COPE set the field-specific reporting items that a results section must contain; those are the role of the family of guidelines coordinated through the EQUATOR Network, such as CONSORT for trials (Hopewell et al., 2025), which address the content of a report rather than how an ethics concern about it should be handled once raised (Moher et al., 2008).
Why it matters
The integrity of the published record depends on ethics concerns being handled fairly, consistently and transparently, rather than quietly or inconsistently across different journals. Where quality of reporting and the conduct behind a published result are poor, readers and meta-analysts can be misled about an intervention's real effect, as has been documented in reporting more generally (Moher et al., 1998); a functioning publication ethics process, applied before and after publication, is part of how the research record stays correctable rather than permanently misleading.
How it is applied in practice
For most doctoral researchers, the most likely encounter with COPE's flowcharts is not a serious misconduct case but a routine query: a plagiarism-detection screen that flags overlapping text with an earlier thesis chapter or conference paper. These queries are almost always resolved quickly once the overlap is explained and properly cited, but responding promptly and fully, exactly as COPE expects an author to, keeps a minor administrative question from becoming a larger one.
Many thousands of journals and publishers are COPE members and commit to following its Core Practices and using its flowcharts when a concern is raised. In practice, when an editor suspects an issue, such as image duplication detected by screening software or a reviewer flagging a possible overlap with another paper, they typically follow the relevant COPE flowchart: contacting the corresponding author for an explanation, consulting the authors' institution where appropriate, and documenting each step before deciding on an outcome such as a correction, an expression of concern, or retraction.
A case report of a clinical patient raises its own specific COPE-relevant questions around consent and identifiability, which sit alongside the structural reporting expectations set out in CARE (Gagnier et al., 2013); an editor handling a complaint about an identifiable patient in a published case report would typically follow COPE guidance on this specific scenario.
Universities increasingly ask doctoral candidates and supervisors to be familiar with COPE's core expectations as part of research integrity training, precisely because many of the situations its flowcharts describe, overlapping submissions from thesis chapters, disputed author order between a student and supervisor, reuse of a student's own earlier conference text, arise naturally during doctoral work rather than only in rare or exceptional cases.
An illustrative example
The passage below is a hypothetical illustration, not a quotation from a real case.
| Situation | Without COPE awareness | With COPE awareness |
|---|---|---|
| Overlapping submission | A chapter is submitted to two journals without telling either editor. | Before submitting, the author discloses to the new journal that related findings were previously published, and explains how this submission differs. |
| Authorship disagreement | A dispute over author order is argued out privately and never resolved before submission. | The author list and order are agreed in writing early, using the ICMJE criteria, and any later disagreement is raised with the editor following COPE's authorship dispute guidance. |
| Suspected image issue | A flagged image discrepancy is ignored, hoping it will not be noticed. | The author responds promptly and fully to the editor's query, providing original data files, consistent with COPE's expectation that authors cooperate with such enquiries. |
| Post-publication concern | A reader's question about an error is dismissed without reply. | The authors acknowledge the question, check the underlying data, and work with the editor on a correction if one is warranted. |
What to check before you submit
- Have you disclosed any closely related prior publication, preprint or conference presentation of the same data?
- Is the author list and order agreed in writing by everyone involved, using the ICMJE criteria (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, 2024)?
- Have you cited your own earlier work wherever you have reused text, figures or data from it?
- If a patient or identifiable individual is described, is consent documented as CARE expects (Gagnier et al., 2013)?
- Do you know who to contact, and what to expect procedurally, if an editor raises a concern after submission?
- Official source: Committee on Publication Ethics (publicationethics.org) .
Key takeaways
- COPE's Core Practices, introduced in 2017, set expectations for how editors and publishers handle publication ethics concerns.
- They exist so that similar concerns, such as suspected duplicate publication or an authorship dispute, are handled through a broadly consistent, fair process across journals.
- COPE provides process guidance; it does not itself investigate specific cases or set authorship criteria, which are ICMJE's role (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, 2024).
- Understanding COPE's flowcharts helps a doctoral researcher avoid common, avoidable problems such as undisclosed overlapping submissions.
- Where a case involves an identifiable patient, COPE guidance sits alongside the consent and reporting expectations in CARE (Gagnier et al., 2013).
