Why thinking and searching belong together
A doctoral dissertation is built on two activities that are easy to treat separately: finding information and thinking about it. In practice they are intertwined. What you search for depends on how you have framed the problem, and how you frame the problem changes as you read. Weak searching starves good reasoning of evidence, and weak reasoning turns a large pile of sources into a summary rather than an argument.
Two models describe these activities well. The critical thinking framework of Paul and Elder (2006) sets out what disciplined reasoning involves. The Information Search Process (ISP) of Kuhlthau (1991) describes what people actually think, feel and do as they search for information on a complex task. Neither was written specifically for doctoral researchers, but together they give a practical map of the literature review stage, where both skills are tested most.
The literature review is not a formality. Boote and Beile (2005) argue that a thorough, sophisticated review is the foundation and inspiration for substantial research, and that the ability to analyse and synthesise a field should be central to doctoral preparation. The two models help explain how that ability develops.

The Paul and Elder model of critical thinking
Definitions of critical thinking vary, but they overlap. An expert panel convened for the American Philosophical Association used a Delphi process to reach consensus on its cognitive skills and dispositions (Facione, 1990), and Halpern (1998) emphasised that critical thinking can be taught for transfer across domains when instruction combines skills, dispositions, structure training and metacognitive monitoring. Paul and Elder's framework is popular in research training because it breaks reasoning into parts that can be checked one at a time (Paul & Elder, 2006).
Elements, standards and traits
- Elements of thought. Every piece of reasoning has a purpose, a question at issue, information, interpretations and inferences, concepts, assumptions, implications and consequences, and a point of view.
- Intellectual standards. The elements are judged against standards such as clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, depth, breadth, logic, significance and fairness.
- Intellectual traits. Applying the standards consistently, over time, builds traits such as intellectual humility, autonomy, integrity, courage, perseverance, empathy, fair-mindedness and confidence in reason.
In the guide's description, a well-cultivated critical thinker raises vital questions and formulates them clearly and precisely, gathers and assesses relevant information, reaches well-reasoned conclusions tested against relevant criteria, thinks open-mindedly within alternative systems of thought, and communicates effectively with others (Paul & Elder, 2006). Each of these maps onto a task in a dissertation: formulating research questions, reviewing literature, drawing conclusions from evidence, engaging with competing theories and writing the thesis.
There is good evidence that these capacities can be developed deliberately. A meta-analysis of strategies for teaching critical thinking found that opportunities for dialogue, exposure to authentic problems and examples, and mentoring were associated with improvement, particularly in combination (Abrami et al., 2015). For doctoral researchers, supervision meetings, reading groups and peer review are natural places for all three.
Kuhlthau's Information Search Process
Kuhlthau developed the ISP from longitudinal studies of high school and college students working on research assignments (Kuhlthau, 1991). Its distinctive contribution is that it describes not only the actions people take but also their thoughts and feelings at each stage. It draws on a constructivist view of learning, in which people build understanding by interpreting new information against what they already know.
Two earlier ideas from information science help explain why searching is hard. Belkin (1980) proposed that people seek information because of an anomalous state of knowledge: they recognise a gap but cannot yet specify what would fill it. Taylor (1968) described information needs moving from a visceral, unexpressed need, through a conscious but rambling need and a formalised statement, to a compromised question shaped to fit what a library or database can answer. A doctoral researcher typing keywords into a database is working at the compromised level, often before the formalised question is clear.
| Stage | Typical task | Typical feelings |
|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Recognising a need for information and understanding the task | Uncertainty, apprehension |
| Selection | Identifying a general area or topic to investigate | Optimism once a choice is made |
| Exploration | Reading widely to become informed about the general topic | Confusion, frustration, doubt |
| Formulation | Forming a focused perspective from what has been read | Growing clarity and confidence |
| Collection | Gathering information relevant to the focus | Sense of direction, increased interest |
| Presentation | Completing the search and using the findings | Relief, satisfaction or disappointment |
The most useful finding for doctoral researchers is what Kuhlthau calls the uncertainty principle: in complex tasks, uncertainty commonly increases during exploration before it falls with the formulation of a focus. A later re-examination of the model in a digital information environment found that it still held for complex tasks that require building understanding, and that the exploratory middle stage is where guidance is most valuable (Kuhlthau et al., 2008). The same study warned that easy access to information tempts people to skip stages and settle for superficial, descriptive knowledge.
Using the two models together in your literature review
The ISP tells you where you are in the process; the critical thinking framework tells you what to do with what you find at each point. The table below pairs them for a doctoral literature review.
| ISP stage | Critical thinking focus | Practical action |
|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Purpose and question at issue | Write a one-paragraph statement of what you need to know and why |
| Selection | Relevance and significance | Choose an area where the question matters to your field and is feasible |
| Exploration | Breadth, assumptions and points of view | Read reviews and key studies from different schools of thought; note what each takes for granted |
| Formulation | Clarity and precision | Draft a focused research question and inclusion criteria for the review |
| Collection | Accuracy, depth and logic | Search systematically, appraise each study's methods and record why sources are kept or excluded |
| Presentation | Implications and fairness | Synthesise the evidence into an argument, representing disagreement fairly |
Choosing the right kind of review also depends on the formulated question. Grant and Booth (2009) describe a range of review types, from scoping and narrative reviews to systematic reviews and meta-analyses, each with different expectations for searching, appraisal and synthesis. A broad scoping search suits the exploration stage; a structured, documented search suits collection once your focus is clear.
A worked example
The following example is illustrative. A doctoral researcher in education is interested in feedback on student writing.
- Initiation and selection. She writes: "I want to understand why written feedback often does not improve later drafts." This states a purpose and an area, but not yet a researchable question.
- Exploration. She reads reviews of feedback research and finds competing assumptions: some studies treat feedback as information transmitted to students, others as a dialogue that students must act on. Her confidence drops because the literature does not agree.
- Formulation. Rather than reading more widely, she writes down the assumptions behind each position and asks which one her study will test. Her focus becomes: "How do first-year undergraduates decide which feedback comments to act on?"
- Collection. She now searches with defined terms, records each database and search string, and appraises each study for sample, setting and method, keeping a log of exclusions.
- Presentation. Her review chapter is organised around the competing assumptions she identified, not around individual papers, and ends with the gap her question addresses.
The critical thinking work happens at every step: questioning assumptions during exploration, insisting on precision at formulation and applying standards of accuracy and relevance during collection.
Academic libraries and information literacy
Doctoral researchers often underuse library expertise. A meta-synthesis of studies of graduate students' information seeking found that doctoral students tend to begin with internet resources and turn first to their supervisors when they need help, and that library use varies considerably by discipline (Catalano, 2013). Subject librarians can advise on databases, controlled vocabularies, citation searching, alerts and reference management, which are exactly the skills the collection stage requires.
The Association of College and Research Libraries frames information literacy as a set of integrated abilities encompassing the reflective discovery of information, understanding how information is produced and valued, and using information to create new knowledge (Association of College and Research Libraries, 2016). Its six frames, which include "Authority is constructed and contextual", "Scholarship as conversation" and "Searching as strategic exploration", read almost as a description of doctoral literature work.
- Book a consultation with your subject librarian early, before your search strategy is fixed.
- Ask which databases and thesauri your discipline relies on, beyond general search engines.
- Learn forward and backward citation searching for your key papers.
- Set up search alerts so that your review stays current until submission.
Common mistakes
- Treating the first set of keywords as final, instead of revising them as your understanding grows.
- Reading for months without writing, so that no focus is ever formulated.
- Judging sources by where they appear rather than by the clarity, accuracy and logic of their methods and claims.
- Summarising papers one by one rather than synthesising them around questions, themes or assumptions.
- Failing to record search strings, databases and dates, which makes the review impossible to update or defend.
- Interpreting the exploration-stage dip in confidence as evidence that the topic is wrong.
Key takeaways
- Critical thinking supplies the standards for judging evidence; the Information Search Process describes how the search itself unfolds (Paul & Elder, 2006; Kuhlthau, 1991).
- Uncertainty that rises during exploration and falls once a focus is formed is a normal feature of complex searches (Kuhlthau et al., 2008).
- Writing a provisional focus statement is the most reliable way through the exploration stage.
- Critical thinking can be developed deliberately through dialogue, authentic problems and mentoring (Abrami et al., 2015).
- Librarians and information literacy frameworks are underused resources for doctoral literature reviews (Catalano, 2013; Association of College and Research Libraries, 2016).
