What a law proposal needs from its sources
A research proposal has to persuade a reader that the question is worth asking and that you can answer it. Guidance on proposal writing stresses being practical, being persuasive, making links to the wider literature and planning before writing (Klopper, 2008), and supervisors look for a clear problem, a credible method and evidence that the candidate knows the field (Kivunja, 2016). In law, "knowing the field" has two layers: knowing where the relevant law is found, and knowing the scholarly debate about it.
Which sources matter depends on the kind of legal research you propose. Doctrinal research analyses legislation and case law to state, systematise and critique the law (Hutchinson & Duncan, 2012), and its standing as a discipline with its own methods continues to be debated (Byrne & Olsen, 2024). Socio-legal and empirical projects also need data about how law works in practice, and they are held to the same rules of inference as other empirical research (Epstein & King, 2002). A review of six law PhD theses found that the quality of their methodological accounts varied, which is a reminder that examiners increasingly expect the method, including how sources were found and selected, to be explicit (Taekema & van Klink, 2023).
Searching can also feel daunting. A study of graduate students writing proposals identified library anxiety, alongside statistics, composition and research-process anxiety, as a component of proposal-writing anxiety (Onwuegbuzie, 1997). Breaking the search into steps, as this guide does, makes it manageable.
Step 1: map primary and secondary legal sources
Primary sources are often described in the general humanities sense (statistics, manuscripts, surveys, government documents). In law the distinction is different and it matters for your proposal. Primary sources are the law itself; secondary sources explain, analyse or criticise it. Secondary sources are a good way to begin, but they are not authority, so each important statement should be traced back to the primary source.
| Source | Examples | Typical places to search | Use in the proposal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legislation (primary) | Acts, statutory instruments, devolved legislation, EU or other foreign law where relevant | Official legislation websites (for example legislation.gov.uk, EUR-Lex); commercial databases | State the legal framework; check the version in force |
| Case law (primary) | Reported and unreported judgments; tribunal decisions | Law reports in Westlaw or LexisNexis; free services such as BAILII; HUDOC for Strasbourg cases | Identify leading authorities and unresolved points |
| Treaties and international materials (primary) | Conventions, treaty texts, official reports of treaty bodies | Official treaty collections and international organisations | Frame comparative or international questions |
| Commentary (secondary) | Journal articles, monographs, textbooks, practitioner works | HeinOnline, Westlaw, LexisNexis, publisher platforms, library catalogues, SSRN | Show the debate and the gap |
| Policy and reform material (secondary) | Law Commission reports, consultation papers, parliamentary debates and committee reports | Official government and parliament websites | Show why the question matters now |
| Empirical data (for socio-legal work) | Court statistics, surveys, interviews, case files | Official statistics, data archives, your own fieldwork | Justify feasibility of the method |
For a fuller tour of UK sources see primary and secondary sources of law for UK research.
Step 2: plan the search before you run it
The 2020 post rightly said that a search is only as good as the topic behind it. Before opening a database, write your provisional research question and three to five sub-questions, then turn them into a search plan.
- Concepts. Split the question into two to four concepts (for example, the legal issue, the actor, the remedy, the jurisdiction).
- Terms. For each concept list synonyms, older and newer legal terms, and the words judges and statutes actually use, which may differ from everyday language.
- Operators. Combine synonyms with OR and concepts with AND; use quotation marks for exact phrases and truncation for word endings, following each database's help pages.
- Filters. Set jurisdiction, court, date range and document type deliberately, and note why.
- Log. Record the database, date, search string, filters and number of results. A proposal that can describe its search strategy is more convincing than one that lists sources.
Then start specific, and if a search returns very little, widen it step by step by relaxing the date range, adding synonyms or including other types of publication. If it returns thousands of results, add a concept or a filter rather than skimming the first page. Natural-language searching in general search engines or Google Scholar is useful for a first orientation, but it is hard to reproduce, so use structured searches for the record you report. See also whether Google is the right place to look for literature.
Step 3: follow citation trails
Database searches miss things, so experienced researchers combine them with citation chasing. Backward chasing means reading the footnotes and reference lists of the best sources you have found; forward chasing means finding later works that cite them. Used systematically, this snowballing approach is a recognised complement to database searching (Wohlin, 2014).
Law adds a third trail: the later judicial treatment of a case. Citator tools in the commercial databases show whether a decision has been followed, distinguished, doubted or overruled, and whether a statutory provision has been amended or repealed. Never rely on a case or section without checking this. It also helps to note the scholars who publish most on your topic and reading their other work; provided you also look for authors who disagree with them.
Finally, judge each source in context. Authority in information is constructed and contextual: a Supreme Court judgment, a peer-reviewed article, a student-edited law review note, a practitioner blog and a newspaper report carry different weight for different purposes (Association of College and Research Libraries, 2016).
Step 4: check that the law is current and the citation is real
Law changes, and a proposal that relies on a repealed section or an overruled case undermines confidence in the whole project. For each key primary source, check the version in force on the date you write, note pending reforms, and record when you checked. For secondary sources, prefer the latest edition of a textbook and note when an article predates a major change in the law.
Generative AI tools can help brainstorm search terms, but they should not be used as a source of citations: a study of ChatGPT-generated bibliographies found that many citations were fabricated and many genuine ones contained errors (Walters & Wilder, 2023). Trace every authority to the official text or the database record, and follow your university's rules on declaring AI use.
Step 5: record and cite as you go
Record full details at the first search, which saves hours later. Use a reference manager or a structured spreadsheet, and store pinpoint references (paragraph or page) for every proposition you may cite. Agree the citation style with your supervisor early. Many UK law schools use OSCOLA, whose fourth edition was published by the Oxford Faculty of Law (Meredith & Nolan, 2010); US law journals generally use The Bluebook; other faculties use their own guides. Check which edition your faculty requires. For citation practice across styles, see referencing sources in a PhD dissertation.
| The proposal should show | How sources help |
|---|---|
| A clear legal problem | Primary sources show the rule and where it is uncertain or contested |
| A gap in scholarship | Recent commentary shows what has and has not been argued |
| Why the question matters now | Reform papers, recent cases and policy debates show topicality |
| A credible method | A described search strategy and source map show the project is feasible |
| Command of the field | Accurate, current, correctly cited authorities |
Worked example: from topic to source map (illustrative)
A candidate wants to study whether consumers can challenge unfair terms in online platform contracts. The first database search for the full sentence returns little of use.
- Question and concepts. "How effectively does the law of [jurisdiction] protect consumers against unfair terms in standard-form platform contracts?" Concepts: unfair terms; consumer; online platform or digital contract; enforcement.
- Terms. unfair term* OR unfair contract term* OR standard form; consumer*; platform* OR "terms of service" OR "click-wrap" OR digital; enforcement OR remedy OR regulator.
- Primary sources. The governing consumer legislation (checked for the version in force), the leading appellate cases on fairness, and any regulator guidance, each checked in a citator.
- Secondary sources. Journal articles found in two databases with the same search string, plus backward and forward chasing from the three most relevant articles.
- Log. Each search recorded with date, database, string, filters and results; sources stored with pinpoints in a reference manager.
The proposal's literature section can then say what the law provides, where courts and commentators disagree, which question remains open in the platform context, and how the thesis will answer it.
Common mistakes
- Treating textbooks or blogs as authority instead of tracing the primary source.
- Citing legislation without checking the version in force, or a case without checking later treatment.
- Searching one database once and reporting the first page of results.
- Using everyday words instead of the legal terms courts and statutes use.
- Copying citations from AI tools or other works without checking them against the source.
- Keeping no record of searches, so the proposal cannot describe its method.
- Mixing citation styles, or using a style your faculty does not accept.
Key takeaways
- A law proposal must show command of both the law and the scholarly debate about it (Klopper, 2008; Kivunja, 2016).
- In law, primary sources are legislation, case law and treaties; commentary is secondary and is not authority (Hutchinson & Duncan, 2012).
- Combine planned database searches with backward and forward citation chasing (Wohlin, 2014).
- Check that every statute is in force and every case remains good law, and verify any AI-suggested citation (Walters & Wilder, 2023).
- Record searches and cite consistently in the style your faculty requires, such as OSCOLA (Meredith & Nolan, 2010).
