PhD Manuscript Editorial Comment Help Service
Get Professional Journal Manuscript Editorial Comment Help Service
Soft & Hard Journal Manuscript Rejection Handling and Reviewer Comments Response Support
Ph.D. Journal Manuscript Editorial Comment Help – From Leading Global Experts
At PhD Assistance Research Lab, we know how challenging it can be to respond to editorial and peer reviewer comments—especially after journal rejection or major revision requests. With editorial expectations getting stricter and review cycles more competitive, even high-quality research can face setbacks due to formatting issues, vague responses, or lack of academic clarity.
That’s where we come in.
Our Editorial Comment Response Team consists of PhD-level experts from some of the top universities around the world and are experienced in responding to editorial, reviewer, and peer comments for journals indexed in Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, IEEE, Springer, Elsevier, Taylor & Francis, and others.
The Challenge
Responding to reviewer comments is more than just responding. You must:
• Understand the reviewer’s intention
• ETA the revision of the manuscript contents
• Fulfil the editorial requirements and formatting directed by the journal
• Explain the changes you have made in a clear manner through a cover letter to the Editor and a rebuttal to the reviewers
• All revisions made need to be original, clear, and follow the given instructions
For most researchers, particularly those with tight timelines or wishing to publish in high-impact journals, it is resource draining to address reviewer comments.
The Solution: Complete Editorial Comment Assistance
At PhD Assistance Research Lab, we provide an end-to-end service for your editorial and reviewer comment responses, including help with revising, reformatting, and resubmitting your manuscript. The order process is easy, confidential, and one where you are supported the entire way through.
Our Guarantees – Premium Manuscript Rejection Handling & Reviewer Comments Response Support
All manuscripts and reviewer responses we revise are 100% human processes and research-based, and at the final stages will be passed through Turnitin, iThenticate, and AI detection programs (e.g., Copyleaks). Again, to ensure our work complies with university or journal requirements regarding the originality policy.
We do not use AI, our revisions passed peer-review population and are ethically grounded and originality-certified.
Every manuscript is handled by a domain expert in your research area, including:
- Engineering & Technology
- Life Sciences & Biomedical Research
- Social Sciences & Public Policy
- Computer Science & AI
- Clinical Medicine & Epidemiology
- Management, Finance & Law
- Humanities & Philosophy
Your revision isn’t just linguistically improved—it’s scientifically enhanced, ensuring both content relevance and academic tone.
We edit your manuscript according to the requirements of the commonest submission plans of publishers such as, Elsevier, Springer, IEEE, Wiley, Wiley SAGE, Nature, etc. We will ensure:
- Correct word count
- Correct referencing style (APA, MLA, Vancouver, etc.)
- Scientific tone and format according to that journal
- File formats will be acceptable
(ex: figures converted to EPS and supplementary files converted to PDF)
We rely only on peer-reviewed, credible databases, including:
- Scopus
- Web of Science
- PubMed
- Springer
- ProQuest
- JSTOR
- IEEE Xplore
- Elsevier
Every source used is traceable, relevant, and cited with precision.
We are a team of editors who are or have been:
- Published authors with familiarity with editors; we know what it is like on either side of the editorial board table
- Subject-matter experts who can provide reasonable technical corrections and can also be used to lend scientific depth
- Language editors and proofreaders who meet academic publishing standards for tone, clarity, and grammar
We respond to line-by-line reviewer comments, we can restructure pieces if needed, and we will explain the corrections made very clearly to the editorial/both, given the time to reflect on and write the comments we received.
We provide unlimited revisions to help you:
- Address comments from reviewers
- Revising or making changes to body sections including methodology or results
- Implement new journal formatting post-rejection
- finalize your manuscript for submission—we revise until approval (within the agreed project scope and time).
We use and update the latest versions of:
- APA (7th edition)
- MLA (9th edition)
- Vancouver
- Harvard
- Chicago
Citation tools include EndNote, Zotero, and Mendeley for formatting references, managing bibliography files, and citation cross-checking.
We understand that deadlines for resubmission can be stressful. Our guaranteed turn-around is:
- Minor revisions – turn-around of 24 hours
- Major revisions and responding to a review – turn-around of 48 hours
Response time – turn-around of under 30 minutes during normal work hours
We always comply with required word counts and formats based on the required journal or university guidelines (e.g. 8,000 to 12,000+ words) — however, it should be noted, tables, references, and appendices are not counted in the word count.
We also provide all of the supporting files that we ensure moral transparency and reusability
- Track-changes and clean document
- Letter response matrix
- Cover letter for journal re-submission
- Correctly formatted supplementary materials
- Originality/plagiarism report (upon request)
Citation and reference library files (Zotero/EndNote)
Whether you just received a full rejection of your manuscript or you received a big revising manuscript, our team will make sure every alteration is made so that the manuscript meets the editorial expectations of your target journal.
Let us help you flip your manuscript around – with clarity, credibility and confidence.
📩 Reach out today to start with our Journal Rejection Handling & Reviewer Response Service.
Our Manuscript Editorial Comments Help Service – By Subject Area
Manuscript Editorial Comments Help Services That We Carry Out
Reviewer Comment Interpretation & Response Drafting
- Evaluate reviewer feedback orienting in terms of major and minor revisions.
- Plan brief, concise, academic, and respectful responses to each comment.
- Check each statement against changes made in the manuscript and use a method for clearly indicating what each revision is.
Reference Addition and Citation Updates
- Incorporate any new references required by the reviewers or any references added to support revisions.
- Ensure all citations comply with the citation style (e.g., APA, Vancouver, MLA, Harvard, etc.) recommended by the journal, including consistency for the revised manuscript.
- Cross-check each reference added using EndNote, Zotero, Mendeley, etc. against original for accuracy and formatting.
Final Similarity Scan & Clean Submission Copy
Reviewer Response Document Preparation
- Writing well organized response letters to reviewer comments (tracked and clean versions).
- Mapping responses point-by-point, with supporting evidence or manuscript citations.
- Keeping a professional tone and clarity that meets the expectations of written academic communications.
Submission-Ready Package Preparation
- A final, revised manuscript for upload.
- A cleaned-up response-to-reviewers letter.
- Any supporting files (figures, tables, appendices) in the requested formats.
- Help with the journal resubmission platform (e.g. Scholar One, Editorial Manager).
Manuscript Revision Based on Editorial Feedback
- Revise content to comply with recommendations from review comments (e.g. analysis and discussion changes, anything structural in the argument, additions of missing data or clarifications).
- Use a tracked document or clean copy, if required by the journal to indicate any changes made.
- Maintain scientific integrity on all content updates for coherence and consistency.
Revision of Visual Elements
- Revise tables and figures to meet reviewer requests (e.g. improving clarity, changing legends, correcting labels)
- Add or remove figures or tables to fit journal and reviewer expectations
- Check internal references and ensure consistency with formatting style across the document
Reviewer Response & Resubmission Support
Ethics, Disclosures, and Statement Adjustments
- If a reviewer/editor requests COI disclosures (or similar disclosures), ethics approval statements, or funding statements, respond to those requests.
- Revising or redeclaring those statements as the journal expects.
- Making sure they appear in both the manuscript and, if necessary, the cover letter.
Cover Letter Preparation
- Write a cover letter specific to the job you are applying for, and the company. Utilize your talents as well as you commit your experiences.
- The letter must have good, proper grammar, clear writing and a professional appearance.
- Proofread for typos or errors in grammar and have someone look it over before you submit it.
Scientific & Academic Language Enhancement
- Rewrites unclear or poorly addressed text to improve clarity, academic voice, and flow.
- The entire manuscript – strengthen arguments, articulate or revise explanations; grow and deepen the logical argument in “Discussion” and “Analysis”.
- Consider any stylistic and structure issues mentioned by the editor or reviewers.
Journal-Specific Formatting After Review
- Reformat the new revised manuscript according to the new journal guidelines.
- Follow any changes to your manuscript such as word-count limits, format for figures/tables, structured abstracts.
- Review any new formatting rules for accepted-with-revisions submissions.
Revision Compliance Checklist
- Conduct a final check over all reviewer and editor instructions to be 100 percent certain you have responded to everything.
- Make sure your responses meet the journal formatting, reference and style requests.
- Check to see that you meet any requirements of their submission policies, including the following: anonymity (if applicable), requirements for supplementary data, and disclosures.
Manuscript Reformatting
We will format your manuscript according to the latest journal’s submission standards, including:
- Figures in PowerPoint, EPS, or high-resolution JPEG
- Supplementary files formatted according to journal guidelines
- Final manuscript file types (DOCX, PDF) depending on submission system guidelines
Order process
Submit Your Requirements and Make Payment
Order Confirmation & Expert Allocation
Regular Updates & Two-Way Communication
Editing, Proofreading & Plagiarism Checking
Review & Revisions
Final Delivery & Feedback
Manuscript Editorial Comments Help –Service Package
We provide three specialized levels of editorial help to fit the needs of researchers responding to journal reviewer comments. Our services allow the requirements for your manuscript revisions to be clear and academically correct, while addressing the expectations of the journal. We are with you from the new manuscript, peer reviewers’ comments or high-impact journals. Our professionals will give you the editorial help you need to get published successfully.
Manuscript Editorial Comments Help & Rejection Response
| Features / Packages | Basic | Standard | Advanced | Premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Editorial Comment Assessment | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Reviewer Comments Summary | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Cover Letter Preparation | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Point-by-Point Rebuttal Letter | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Track Changes Editing (Marked + Clean) | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Language Editing & Clarity Improvement | ❌ | ✔️ (minor) | ✔️ (moderate) | ✔️ (comprehensive) |
| Restructuring Manuscript (Section by Section) | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Journal Formatting & Compliance (Word Count, References, Figures) | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Support for Hard Rejections (Resubmission to New Journal) | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Reviewer Response Letter Formatting | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Resubmission Package (Clean + Response Matrix + Files) | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Figure/Table Reformatting per Journal Style | ❌ | Optional | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Journal Targeting Suggestions | ❌ | ❌ | Optional | ✔️ |
| Expert Consultation Call (Subject-Matter Expert) | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ (30 min) | ✔️ (60 min) |
| Unlimited Revisions (within 7–14 days) | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Turnaround Time | 4–5 days | 3–4 days | 2–3 days | 1–2 days |
Comments We Offer at PhD Assistance Research Lab
At PhD Assistance Research Lab, we offer extensive editorial comments and suggestions to enable you to tackle reviewer suggestions and/or improve the manuscript quality. Thus, we ensure your work meets the publication’s requirements and expectations and below is a description of the editorial comments we offer to help you through the peer-review and revision process.
Rebuttal Letter
Point by Point Rebuttal we help you draft a rebuttal letter where each of the reviewer’s comments are addressed individually, and we specify how you addressed each comment or provided explanations for why a comment was not addressed.
Professional and Respectful Tone We obtain to ensure our response is measured, expressing thanks for constructive feedback, while defending the research where appropriate and necessary.
Content & Structural Revision Comments
Content Improvements:
We will provide comments about the content quality of your writing, regarding clarity and precision in reasoning.
Structure:
We will have comments about the structure of your manuscript (Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion) and may recommend some re-organization if we feel it is warranted.
Language and Grammar Comments
Improving Readability:
We will have suggestions to improve sentence structure, grammar, punctuation and spelling to improve your manuscript considerably, and put a more scholarly and professional polish on your academic writing.
Clarity and Conciseness:
We will provide suggestions about redundancy and clarity to ensure the reader has no difficulty understanding your manuscript, and to enhance the smooth readability of the manuscript.
Formatting and Style Comments
We ensure that your manuscript follows the formatting specific to the journal that you are submitting to. We check that the layout, referencing style, as well as sections like Abstract, Introduction, and Discussion are consistent throughout your manuscript.
We also will refine your manuscript in terms of overall structure and tone in the language used, to both meet the requirements of the discipline and the journal.
Figures Tables&Visual Elements Feedback
Visuals Evaluation:
We evaluate the figures, tables, graphs and visuals in the manuscript and determine that they are visually clear, labelled appropriately and in the correct format requested by the journals
Recommendations for Potential Improvement:
Where appropriate, we provide recommendations for improvements of the layout, colour choices, labels and captions in the figures to improve the presentation of the visual data.
Cover Letter & Supplementary Material
Your cover letter is designed to accentuate the novelty, significance, and journal fit of your manuscript. We also assess supplementary materials (such as appendices, datasets, figures) to ensure they are properly formatted and that the journal’s technical and ethical submission protocols are met.
Whom We Serve – Manuscript Editorial Comments Help Service
If you are a PhD candidate or doctoral researcher looking to publish your dissertation research, our editorial comment service will provide you with support so that your manuscript effectively and efficiently responds to reviewer feedback. We assist:
- Clarifying, rewriting content, based on reviewer rationale
- Structuring responses to comments and revising tracked changes documents
- Enhancing your clarity and strength of arguments and coherence with journal expectations
We partner with academic departments, academic staff (supervisors) and university writing centers to provide editorial response support to university-sponsored research in a way that is compliant with university expectations of ethics and publishing policies. We help universities and organizations:
- Facilitate the peer-review cycle for their students and staff Support their university sponsored research articles will meet the editorial guidelines for a journal
- Develop and prepare post-review documents for resubmission.
We work with postdoctoral fellows, leading scholars, independent authors in many fields including: medicine, law, psychology, engineering, and the social sciences who need professional assistance in drafting responses to peer reviewers. We can help by:
- Preparing detailed and professional response-to-reviewer documents
- Revising manuscripts for tone, clarity, and academic quality.
- Identifying how best to respond to the comments made by the reviewers in the context of high-impact journals.
Our subject-matter editors work with clinical and biomedical researchers who have submitted manuscripts that are currently being reviewed. Whether the reviewers are concerned about the methods, need clear ethical justifications or asking you to clarify your results, we always ensure that we respect:
- Scientific integrity and the review requests made by the reviewers.
- Journals like: BMJ, The Lancet, NEJM, among others.
Corporate researchers and R&D departments usually publish reports in peer-reviewed or industry journals. We assist all corporate researchers and R&D employees with:
- Revisions of technical manuscripts that require acceptance from the journal editorial boards.
- Assistance with drafting detailed point-by-point replies to the comments made by the reviewers.
We support international researchers—whether based in the UK, USA, Australia, UAE, India, or Europe—who have to revise and resubmit manuscripts based on journal and regional expectations. Our services include:
- Refining language and tone for non-native English speakers
- Following journal-specific response formats
Check at what stage you’re into & Analyse how you can fit into our engagement model
Charlotte
Reviewer Comment Interpretation & Results Rewriting We assist you in interpreting the reviewers' expected expectations, especially regarding reporting statistics, and then help you to translate technical input into clear improvements; in this case, it is rewriting your results section including accurate p-values, effect sizes, and confidence intervals in a journal appropriate format.
Emily
Clarification of Test Selection and Editorial Revision We help you to describe why each statistical test was used, in relation to your variables, design, and aims of research. We will edit your manuscript and your point-by-point response to reviewers, so it is clear, and follows scientific principles.
James
Statistical Method Justification for Reviewer Comments We assist you in writing accurate and scholarly responses in defending your analytical choices - logistic vs. linear regression or how to defend choices related model fit. We provide you with methodological rigor, ensuring your response is actively related to your research context, so this comment is easily justified.
Thomas
Assumption Checking and Robustness Reporting for Peer Review We help you document how you verified that your data satisfied statistical assumptions e.g. normality, multicollinearity, model fit, as well as help you document robustness checks. We edit your manuscript and reviewer responses to depict scientific rigor.
Our Guarantee
Plagiarism Free
Unlimited Support
On-time delivery
Subject Matter Expertise
Communicate with your writer
Updated academic resources
Free research articles supply*
Our Sample & Example Works Speaks
We take pride in the quality of work we deliver. To know more, just look at some of our samples developed by writers at PhD Assistance Research Lab. The samples are a testimony of our expertise, while reflecting quality. By perusing these samples, you will get an idea of our versatility across topics and subject domains.
Client success stories
PhD Assistance Research Lab Service
Expert Support in Responding to Reviewer Critiques
"I became unsure how to proceed with a review comment that questioned my statistical method (whether linear regression or ANOVA was better). The PhD Assistance Research Lab assisted me draft a methodologically sound justification and proposal to change my methods section. Further the lab's suggestions about assumption testing and model fit improved my response."
— Sophie Laurent, France, PhD Student
Rapid Turnaround for Revision Deadline
"I only had days until the revision deadline from my manuscript. I first had to accommodate the reviewer's comments on the multivariate analysis I used in my manuscript. The PhD Assistance Research Lab again edited the paper on a timely turnaround format (revised tables, clarity of the analysis outputs, and a letter to response). Ultimately, their service assured I would not miss my resubmission deadline."
— Jonas Weber, Doctoral Student, Germany
Thorough Interpretation for Revised Results Section
"After seeing offerings of 'editorial comment' service from the company, I decided to pay for the service. The writers revised my results section with persuasive explanations of the odds ratios and confidence intervals and added comparisons based on previously referenced studies. Their suggestions made my replies scientifically convincing, and they fit reviewer preferences."
— Isabella Rossi, Medical Researcher, Italy
Well-Structured Quality Deliverable
"A reviewer wanted a better structured set of statistical tables and some clarity on my regression output. PhD assistance's research lab formatted everything exactly, in journal style, added short annotations and were careful to be consistent with my manuscript. The professionalism and care shown in their deliverables was exceptional."
— Erik Lindholm, Data Analyst, Sweden
Close Inspection of Statistical Validity
"A reviewer questioned the robustness of my analysis and my model's assumptions. The editorial support team did a comprehensive check-up: they produced several diagnostic checks (residual analysis, multicollinearity varibles and justified the model). The detailed feedback I received helped me address improvements in my manuscript and my comment back to the editor."
— Marta Novak, PhD Scholar in Epidemiology, Poland
Affordable Pricing"
“I fully admire PhD assistance's reputation and quality. I especially chose PhD assistance's packages as no other company offers such a service. Their service quality and timely delivery is very helpful in meeting journal deadlines. I am glad that PhD assistance offers packages at affordable price.”
-Kate Merkel-Hess
Supportive brainstorming and topic discovery
"Picking a topic for my PhD felt like looking for a needle in a haystack. I was lost until I found the topic selection guidance service at PhD Assistance. They were like personal academic cheerleaders—helping me discover what I truly cared about and could research meaningfully. It was like a brainstorming session with friends who knew their stuff. Now I’m excited to dive into my research and make a difference!"
PhD topic clarity and direction
"Choosing a PhD topic was a total headache until I stumbled upon the PhD Thesis Dissertation Topics Help UK at PhD Assistance. Let me tell you—these guys are wizards when it comes to turning confusion into clarity. They didn’t just throw random ideas at me; they took the time to understand what I was passionate about and what I wanted to achieve. It felt like having a coffee chat with a smart friend who knows all about PhDs. Thanks to their help, I finally feel like I’m on the right track and ready to tackle anything that comes my way!"
Stress-free topic selection in Computer Science
"I was very confused about selecting a research topic for my PhD in computer science. It was stressful and overwhelming. A friend recommended PhD Assistance—and it was the best decision. The expert helped me choose a topic that my guide accepted without any changes. Thank you, PhD Assistance!"
Confidence-building experience
"I recommend PhD Assistance to anyone needing help with research topic selection. I was hesitant at first, but after meeting the team, I gained confidence in articulating my ideas clearly. The title they provided matched exactly what I had in mind—it felt like they had read my thoughts. Thank you!"
Structured support for academic success
"I was feeling overwhelmed and lost when it came to choosing a PhD topic that would truly excite me and contribute to the field. Thankfully, the topic selection service at PhD Assistance gave me invaluable support. They took the time to understand my interests, strengths, and goals and curated a list of focused research areas. I found a topic that reignited my passion. Thank you, team!"
John, France
Flexible and student-friendly service
"PhD Assistance offered me great flexibility in choosing courses and research areas. The specialists helped me identify a unique and meaningful topic. It gave me a strong foundation to move confidently into the next stage of my research."
Liam
Supportive brainstorming and topic discovery
"Picking a topic for my PhD felt like looking for a needle in a haystack. I was lost until I found the topic selection guidance service at PhD Assistance. They were like personal academic cheerleaders—helping me discover what I truly cared about and could research meaningfully. It was like a brainstorming session with friends who knew their stuff. Now I’m excited to dive into my research and make a difference!"
Supportive brainstorming and topic discovery
"Picking a topic for my PhD felt like looking for a needle in a haystack. I was lost until I found the topic selection guidance service at PhD Assistance. They were like personal academic cheerleaders—helping me discover what I truly cared about and could research meaningfully. It was like a brainstorming session with friends who knew their stuff. Now I’m excited to dive into my research and make a difference!"
Quality & Compliances
Frequently Asked Questions.
Yes, we have experts that know all the styles – Harvard, APA, MLA, Vancouver, Chicago, etc. – and can format papers to all the major publishers, Springer, Oxford, Elsevier, ScienceDirect, etc.
We provide full support to researchers with completing responses to journal reviewer comments so that the manuscript can be readied for academic standards and publication.
Our main services include:
- Reviewer Comment Response
Mapping reviewer comments
Drafting direct and clear point by point response
- Manuscript Revisions
Rewriting content responding to comments
improving clarity, coherence, and scientific accuracy
- Statistical Justification & Clarity
Justifying responding statistical methods & reporting statistical results in lay context, where needed by reviewers
Ensuring that testing and reporting analysis follow journal guidelines
- Formatting & Compliance
Organizing tables, figures, and references to meet journal structure
- Language & Technical editing
Editing for grammar, structure, and academic tone
- Final checks & resubmission support
Proofreading and cover letter support for resubmission
Ph.D. Assistance helps to modify the manuscript as suggested by the reviewers. We respond to the reviewer comments line by line and section by section and revise manuscript thoroughly, including correcting any awkward English expressions.
- Ethical issues in research study
- Adequately supported statements in support of research
- Appropriate conclusion with the evidence of data
- Reader-friendly content
- Avoidance of excessive jargons and abbreviations
- Content of the manuscript in context to journal style and format
- Consistency in the content of the manuscript, etc.
We are committed to providing excellent manuscript editorial comment addressal services as per your requirement. We look the articles from your own perspective and explain how you ‘see’ it. Being kind, yet honest, in the process. Our experts having equipped with all the relevant sources and their understanding of the need of journal manuscript is worth seeking their help.
Pricing by Ph.D. Assistance Research Lab is fair as compared to others, but the quality of the writing is unbeatable. We also facilitate seasonal discount plan, and referral offers for our customers. Please contact our project coordinators for further information.
No. We are not charging extra amount for any revision of the document. We do any numbers of revisions until our customers get satisfied. To know more details about revisions and other inquiries. Please feel free to conduct our project coordinators or request a call back on the website to get the call back from experts. You may also please read our terms and conditions while placing an order.
Insights
