Critical reviewMethodology & analyticsBusiness & management

Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024)

Management journals increasingly invite research that crosses disciplinary boundaries. This review examines an Academy of Management Journal editorial on how interdisciplinary work can advance management theory, considers what kind of evidence stands behind its advice, and shows how doctoral researchers can integrate other disciplines rather than simply borrow from them.

What you will learn

  • Identify the source, genre and main argument of Reinecke et al. (2024)
  • Distinguish multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research
  • Evaluate the kind of evidence an editorial offers and how to cite it
  • Relate the editorial to research on grand challenges, problematisation and the evaluation of interdisciplinary work
  • Plan how to integrate a second discipline into a management thesis

What you will unlearn

  • Citing a few papers from another field makes a study interdisciplinary.Interdisciplinary research integrates concepts, methods or theories so that the combination yields something neither field offers alone.
  • An editorial in a leading journal is evidence that an approach works.An editorial is reasoned guidance from experienced editors; it sets expectations but does not test them.
  • Interdisciplinary research is always more original than disciplinary research.It can be, but integration is demanding, and shallow borrowing can produce weaker theory than careful disciplinary work.
  • Doctoral researchers should avoid interdisciplinary topics.They can pursue them well with a clear home discipline, a defined point of integration and supervisors who cover both fields.

Skills you will practise

  • Critical appraisal
  • Theory building
  • Interdisciplinary integration
  • Research design
  • Evaluating editorial guidance
  • Positioning a contribution

The source and why it matters

The source under review is Reinecke et al. (2024), "Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: Challenges and opportunities", published in the Academy of Management Journal (volume 67, issue 6, pages 1421 to 1427) in December 2024. It is an editorial written by eight authors from the journal's editorial team, in the journal's From the Editors series, rather than an empirical article.

Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research
Figure 1. Critical review of advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research.

The genre matters for how it should be read. Editorials in this series set out what editors look for and how authors might meet those expectations; earlier examples have addressed grand challenges (George et al., 2016) and the contribution of qualitative research (Bansal et al., 2018). They influence what gets submitted and how it is reviewed, which is why doctoral researchers in management should know them. They are, however, arguments informed by editorial experience, not studies that test their own claims.

The topic is timely. Many problems that management scholars now study, such as climate adaptation, inequality, health systems or artificial intelligence at work, do not respect disciplinary boundaries. Problems of this kind resemble what Rittel and Webber (1973) called wicked problems: they have no definitive formulation, and how they are framed shapes what counts as a solution. Calls to tackle grand challenges through management research have stressed the need for coordinated effort across fields (George et al., 2016).

What the editorial argues

The editorial argues that interdisciplinary research can advance management theory, and sets out the challenges authors face in doing so. Its starting point is a distinction between kinds of cross-disciplinary work. The comparison below follows the distinction widely used in the literature; the editorial's argument concerns the middle column.

Three forms of cross-disciplinary research (illustrative examples)
MultidisciplinaryInterdisciplinaryTransdisciplinary
Relationship between fieldsSide by side; each keeps its own frameConcepts, methods or theories are integratedGoes beyond disciplines, usually with non-academic partners
Typical outputParallel analyses of one topicA combined explanation or new constructKnowledge co-produced for a practical problem
Main riskNo real synthesisShallow or one-sided borrowingLosing theoretical depth or scholarly rigour
Example in managementAn edited volume with economic and sociological chapters on one industryA theory of team decisions that integrates neuroscience measures with organisational constructsResearchers and hospital staff jointly redesigning a care pathway

On the opportunity side, the editorial presents interdisciplinary research as a source of theoretical innovation, because ideas from another discipline can challenge assumptions that management research takes for granted; as a route to new methods and data; and as suited to societal challenges that cut across fields. Its central point is that advancing management theory requires integration, not the importation of an idea from another field without adapting it (Reinecke et al., 2024).

On the challenge side, the editorial discusses recurring problems in interdisciplinary submissions: an unclear motivation for crossing disciplines, difficulties of communicating with readers trained in different traditions, theorising that remains shallow on one side of the combination, and institutional constraints on doing this kind of work. It then offers guidance on how authors can address each in framing, theorising and writing (Reinecke et al., 2024).

Strengths

  • It insists on integration. Separating genuine interdisciplinarity from citation of another field gives authors and reviewers a usable standard, and it matches a long-standing concern in the wider literature that integration is the hardest and most important part of such work (Klein, 2008).
  • It links interdisciplinarity to theory. Framing other disciplines as a way to unsettle management assumptions connects the editorial to the case for problematisation over gap-spotting (Alvesson & Sandberg, 2011; Sandberg & Alvesson, 2011).
  • It is practical. Naming recurring problems in submissions tells authors where interdisciplinary manuscripts tend to fail, which is valuable for early-career researchers preparing their first papers.
  • It carries institutional weight. Guidance from the editors of a leading journal signals that interdisciplinary work is welcome, which matters to doctoral researchers deciding whether such a topic is a career risk.

Limitations and questions for the reader

An editorial should be judged as an editorial. It is not a weakness that it reports no data; it is a reason to cite it accurately. Several points nevertheless deserve critical attention.

  • Experience rather than systematic evidence. Statements about what tends to go wrong in submissions rest on the editors' experience. A systematic analysis of interdisciplinary submissions, their reviews and outcomes would show whether the problems identified are the most common ones, and whether interdisciplinary papers are treated differently in review.
  • The evaluation problem. Interdisciplinary work is hard to evaluate: Klein (2008) called evaluation one of its least understood aspects and argued that criteria must vary with the goals of the research. Readers may ask how far reviewers trained in one discipline can judge integration, and whether journal review processes themselves need to change, not only author behaviour.
  • Epistemological differences. Disciplines differ not only in vocabulary but in what counts as evidence and explanation. Combining an interpretive sociological concept with an econometric design, for example, raises questions of commensurability that guidance on clear communication cannot resolve alone.
  • Careers and institutions. Interdisciplinary researchers can face a lack of recognition from the institutions that hire, fund and promote them (Salmela et al., 2026). Advice to authors works within these structures; doctoral researchers should know that the barriers are partly institutional, not only a matter of writing skill.

In a literature review it is fair to cite Reinecke et al. as setting out the Academy of Management Journal editors' view of how interdisciplinary research can advance management theory and what makes such submissions succeed. It would overstate the source to cite it as evidence that interdisciplinary research produces better theory.

How the editorial sits in the wider literature

Three bodies of work help to position the editorial. The first concerns how theory advances. Sandberg and Alvesson (2011) found that most published studies construct questions by gap-spotting, and Alvesson and Sandberg (2011) argued that challenging the assumptions behind a literature produces more interesting theory. Another discipline is one of the most effective sources of such challenges, because it makes management's taken-for-granted assumptions visible.

The second concerns method. Integration often happens through design: Aguinis and Molina-Azorín (2015) argue that combining multilevel modelling with mixed methods can link individual-level and organisational phenomena, a problem that often requires concepts from psychology and economics alike. Case study research can also build theory from rich data across contexts (Eisenhardt, 1989), which suits questions where no single discipline offers an adequate starting theory.

The third concerns the researcher. Interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary scholars report institutional, social and psychological challenges, which Salmela et al. (2026) frame as a problem of recognition. For professional doctorates in management, which draw on practice as well as theory (Banerjee & Morley, 2013), the question of how to integrate knowledge from several fields arises from the start.

What it means for doctoral researchers

The editorial's emphasis on integration translates into a set of design decisions. The table sets them out; it is our synthesis for doctoral use, not a summary of the editorial.

Planning integration in an interdisciplinary management thesis
DecisionQuestion to answerEvidence in the thesis
Home disciplineWhich field's debate am I contributing to?A clearly stated contribution to management theory
MotivationWhat can the second field explain that management theory cannot?A specific limitation in existing theory that the borrowed idea addresses
Point of integrationWhere exactly do the fields meet: a construct, a mechanism, a method?A defined construct or model showing the combination
TranslationHave borrowed concepts kept their meaning, or been adapted with reasons?Definitions traced to their source field
MethodsDo my methods meet the standards of both fields?Justification addressed to readers from each field
SupervisionWho can judge each side of the work?A supervisory team or adviser from the second field

Worked example (illustrative)

Suppose a doctoral researcher wants to study why nurses leave hospital employment. A multidisciplinary version would report burnout findings from occupational psychology alongside staffing data from operations management. An interdisciplinary version starts from a gap in management theory, for example that turnover models treat workload as an individual perception, and integrates an operations concept of schedule volatility as an organisational mechanism that produces that perception. The thesis then specifies how the two connect, measures both with methods each field would accept, and states its contribution to turnover theory. Bringing nurses and managers in to co-design an intervention would move the project towards transdisciplinary research, with different standards for success.

The example also shows how to use the editorial in the thesis itself. In the introduction, it can support the claim that leading management journals welcome integrative work and expect it to contribute to management theory. In the theoretical framework chapter, it can help you explain why integration, rather than borrowing, is the standard you hold yourself to. It cannot, however, replace the substantive literature from each field: examiners will expect you to show that you understand the second discipline on its own terms, cite its foundational work, and anticipate how a specialist from that field would read your use of its concepts. A short paragraph in the methods chapter stating which standards from each field your design meets, and where you have had to compromise, shows the reflexivity that interdisciplinary examiners look for and prepares you for questions at the viva.

For the earlier stages of shaping such a topic, see our guide to research directions in management and the review of research question development. Legal research faces similar demands when it combines disciplines, as the review of progress in legal methodology shows.

Common mistakes in interdisciplinary management research

  • Borrowing a fashionable concept from another field without tracing its original meaning.
  • Failing to say which discipline's debate the thesis contributes to.
  • Theorising deeply on the management side and superficially on the other, or the reverse.
  • Combining methods from two fields without justifying how their assumptions fit.
  • Writing for one audience only, so that readers from the second field cannot follow the argument.
  • Treating an editorial or position paper as empirical evidence for a claim.

Key takeaways

  • Reinecke et al. (2024) is an Academy of Management Journal editorial setting out how interdisciplinary research can advance management theory.
  • Its key standard is integration: combining fields so that the result explains what neither could alone.
  • As an editorial it offers reasoned guidance, not tested evidence, and should be cited accordingly.
  • Evaluation and recognition of interdisciplinary work remain open problems for reviewers and institutions (Klein, 2008; Salmela et al., 2026).
  • Doctoral researchers can integrate a second field by naming a home discipline, a motivation and a precise point of integration (Alvesson & Sandberg, 2011).
Your next step

Want to apply this to your own study?

  1. 1Tell us your topic, data and deadline
  2. 2A subject mentor reviews your work with you
  3. 3You get a plan and a quote
Theoretical framework

References

  1. Aguinis, H., & Molina-Azorín, J. F. (2015). Using multilevel modeling and mixed methods to make theoretical progress in microfoundations for strategy research. Strategic Organization, 13(4), 353–364. https://doi.org/10.1177/1476127015594622
  2. Alvesson, M., & Sandberg, J. (2011). Generating research questions through problematization. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 247–271. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0188
  3. Banerjee, S., & Morley, C. (2013). Professional doctorates in management: Toward a practice-based approach to doctoral education. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 12(2), 173–193. https://doi.org/10.5465/amle.2012.0159
  4. Bansal, P., Smith, W. K., & Vaara, E. (2018). New ways of seeing through qualitative research. Academy of Management Journal, 61(4), 1189–1195. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2018.4004
  5. Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Building theories from case study research. Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 532–550. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1989.4308385
  6. George, G., Howard-Grenville, J., Joshi, A., & Tihanyi, L. (2016). Understanding and tackling societal grand challenges through management research. Academy of Management Journal, 59(6), 1880–1895. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2016.4007
  7. Klein, J. T. (2008). Evaluation of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research: A literature review. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 35(2, Suppl.), S116–S123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2008.05.010
  8. Reinecke, J., Little, L. M., Simons, T., Bliese, P., Dencker, J., Roberson, Q., von Krogh, G., & Gruber, M. (2024). Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: Challenges and opportunities. Academy of Management Journal, 67(6), 1421–1427. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2024.4006
  9. Rittel, H. W. J., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730
  10. Salmela, M., Vienni-Baptista, B., & Cheas, K. (2026). Towards the recognition of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary researchers. Minerva, 64, 367–386. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11024-025-09578-y
  11. Sandberg, J., & Alvesson, M. (2011). Ways of constructing research questions: Gap-spotting or problematization? Organization, 18(1), 23–44. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508410372151

How to cite this article

Choose your referencing style, then copy. Check your university's or journal's guide for local variations.

PhD Research Lab Academy. (2026, January 19). Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024). PhD Research Lab. https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory/

PhD Research Lab Academy. “Advancing Management Theory Through Interdisciplinary Research: A Critical Review of Reinecke Et Al. (2024).” PhD Research Lab, 19 Jan. 2026, www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory. Accessed [access date].

PhD Research Lab Academy (2026) Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024). PhD Research Lab. Available at: https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory/ (Accessed: [access date]).

PhD Research Lab Academy. “Advancing Management Theory Through Interdisciplinary Research: A Critical Review of Reinecke Et Al. (2024).” PhD Research Lab. January 19, 2026. https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory.

PhD Research Lab Academy, ‘Advancing Management Theory Through Interdisciplinary Research: A Critical Review of Reinecke Et Al. (2024)’ (PhD Research Lab, 19 January 2026) <https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory> accessed [access date].

PhD Research Lab Academy. Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024) [Internet]. PhD Research Lab; 2026 Jan 19 [cited [access date]]. Available from: https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory/

PhD Research Lab Academy, “Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024),” PhD Research Lab, Jan. 19, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory. [Accessed: [access date]].

@online{research_management_theory_2026,
  author = {{PhD Research Lab Academy}},
  title = {{Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary research: a critical review of Reinecke et al. (2024)}},
  organization = {PhD Research Lab},
  date = {2026-01-19},
  url = {https://www.phdassistance.com/academy/critical-review/research-management-theory},
  urldate = {[access date]}
}

This article is for learning. Use it to understand the method and cite the original sources above in your own work; do not copy or submit it as your own.

Advancing management theory through interdisciplinary researchNeed help applying it to your study?
Theoretical framework