The source and why it matters
The article under review is Burns (2026), "Living rhythms: Investigating networks and relational sensorial island rhythms through artistic research", published in the open-access journal Arts (volume 15, issue 2, article 31) in February 2026. The author is an artist and independent researcher based in Cork, Ireland. The paper reports and reflects on Rhythmanalysis+, an immersive virtual reality (VR) drawing and soundscape made from the daily lives of four residents of Sherkin Island, a small island off the south-west coast of Ireland with about 100 inhabitants.

The paper matters to doctoral researchers for a methodological reason. Practice-based and artistic research degrees ask candidates to show that making art can be a way of producing knowledge, not only an object to be interpreted. Borgdorff (2012) argued that art practice counts as research when it sets out to extend understanding through an original investigation conducted in and through artworks and creative processes, and when that process is documented and shared. Loveless (2019) makes a related case for "research-creation" as a mode of inquiry in its own right. Burns's project is a useful test case for these arguments: it uses a recognised analytic idea, works with participants, and makes explicit claims about what was learned.
What the study did and claimed
The project began during the COVID-19 restrictions, when face-to-face fieldwork was impossible. Its theoretical starting point is Henri Lefebvre's rhythmanalysis, which studies everyday life through the interplay of cyclical rhythms (days, tides, seasons) and linear rhythms (work, routine, repetition) (Lefebvre, 2004). Burns combines this with Édouard Glissant's archipelagic and relational thought (Glissant, 1997), with Deleuze and Guattari's image of the rhizome (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987), and with the tracings of children's movements made by Fernand Deligny and his collaborators (Deligny, 2015).
Four islanders, recruited through relationships formed in an earlier community project, documented their daily rhythms for four weeks using voice notes, sound recordings, photographs, drawings and diaries. Each took part in a one-hour Zoom interview with open questions about routines. While listening, the artist drew large maps on brown paper in charcoal, pencil and earth pigments, recording pathways, weather, tides, the flight of birds and bats, and encounters between people and animals. Environmental sounds and participants' voices were edited into a soundscape of just over five minutes. Using the maps as scaffolding, the artist then drew inside a VR headset with Gravity Sketch, producing a life-size, slowly revolving 360-degree drawing that surrounds the viewer. The work was exhibited with a headset on a plinth, and the artist invigilated throughout the exhibition (Burns, 2026).
- 1Islanders record their daily rhythms for four weeks
- 2Remote interviews; the artist draws sensory maps while listening
- 3Sounds and voices edited into a soundscape
- 4Maps used as scaffolding for drawing in VR
- 5Exhibition of the 360-degree work; informal observation of viewers
The paper makes three main claims. First, rhythm should be understood as multi-sensory, relational and produced with the environment and other species, not only as a pattern in time. Second, contact during isolation need not depend on physical proximity; it can arise through perceptual and embodied attention, which VR can support. Third, VR can serve as a research medium in which ethnographic sensory maps become spatial drawings, so that rhythm is both method and material. Burns also reports that viewers reached, paused and listened inside the headset, which she reads as attempts at perceptual contact, and she draws on phenomenology (Merleau-Ponty, 2012), the extended mind thesis (Clark & Chalmers, 1998) and multispecies thinking (Haraway, 2016) to interpret this (Burns, 2026).
Strengths
- A transparent account of making. The paper describes materials, tools, formats, durations and the order of steps in enough detail for a reader to follow how the work came about. This is the documentation that Borgdorff (2012) treats as a condition of artistic research.
- Theory used as a working tool. Rhythmanalysis is not decoration: it shapes what participants were asked to record (cycles, routines, pathways) and how the maps were drawn (Lefebvre, 2004).
- Reciprocal, non-extractive ethics. Participants could omit, revise or withdraw material at any stage, were told how their material would be translated and had access to the finished work.
- Honest limitations. Burns acknowledges the small group, the four-week window, the informal audience evidence, her own learning curve with the software and the fact that the 2022 VR file is now technically fixed and cannot be edited.
- Disclosure of AI use. The acknowledgements state that a generative AI tool was used for structural help with the manuscript, which is the transparency journals now expect.
Methodological issues
From data to artwork: an untraceable translation
The central methodological step is the translation of participants' recordings and stories into marks, colours and movements in VR. The paper describes the tools and the iterative experimentation, but not the decision rules: why a given encounter became a particular line, what was left out, and how the artist checked that the work still answered to participants' accounts. Without a record of these choices, such as annotated sketches, a decision log or participants' comments on draft maps, readers cannot tell which features of the work come from the islanders' rhythms and which from the artist's aesthetic judgement. Both are legitimate, but a research claim needs them to be distinguishable.
Claims about viewers rest on informal observation
The claim that viewers' reaching and pausing were forms of "perceptual contact" is interpretively rich but evidentially thin. The observations were made informally by the artist while invigilating, with no recorded protocol, no count of how many visitors behaved in which ways, and no viewers' own accounts. Reaching towards objects in a headset is also a common response to VR in general, so it cannot by itself show the effect of these particular rhythms. Burns recognises the lack of formal audience data; the conclusion would be better framed as a proposition for further study than as a finding.
One researcher in every role
The artist recruited participants through prior relationships, interviewed them, drew the maps, composed the VR work, invigilated the exhibition and interpreted viewers' responses. This is normal in artistic research, but it places heavy weight on reflexivity: an account of how the researcher's position, relationships and expectations shaped what was asked, heard, drawn and seen. Criteria for qualitative quality such as sincerity, credibility and meaningful coherence (Tracy, 2010) offer a vocabulary for this account that examiners in practice-based fields will recognise.
Scope of the claims
Four participants over four weeks suit an in-depth, idiographic inquiry, and Burns argues that the small group intensified the work. Statements about how "islanders" responded to the pandemic, however, reach beyond four people on one island. Phrasing such findings as insights from these participants, and naming the rhythms a four-week window cannot capture (seasons, the farming and fishing year, breeding cycles), would match the claims to the evidence.
Ethics, identifiability and archiving
The paper states that the project was minimal-risk, non-clinical creative practice that fell outside the remit of Ireland's National Research Ethics Committees, so no formal ethics review was required, and that informed consent was obtained (Burns, 2026). For an independent artist that position is understandable. A doctoral candidate would be in a different situation: universities generally require their own ethics review for research that records people's voices, routines and images, whatever the national position.
The setting raises a specific risk. On an island of about 100 people, descriptions of daily routes, routines, voices and relationships may make participants recognisable to neighbours, even without names. Burns notes that some participants chose to leave out difficult relationships, which shows the consent process working, but the paper does not discuss identifiability directly. The data are not publicly available for privacy reasons, which is appropriate. A further issue is the life of the output: the 2022 VR work can no longer be edited. For a thesis, examiners need stable access to the work, so a doctoral project should plan an archive of the files, a video capture of the experience and a record of the software versions used.
Matching claims to evidence
The table summarises the paper's main claims, the evidence offered for each and what would strengthen it. It is the reviewer's analysis, not a table from the paper.
| Claim | Evidence in the paper | What would strengthen it |
|---|---|---|
| Rhythm is multi-sensory, relational and co-produced with the environment | Participants' recordings, interviews and the sensory maps | Showing, map by map, how participants' material produced each element, ideally with participants' comments |
| Contact can occur through perception and embodied attention during isolation | Participants' accounts of care at a distance; the artist's interpretation | Participants' own reflections on the finished work; linking examples to the theory used |
| Viewers made "perceptual contact" with the rhythms in VR | Informal observation during invigilation | A planned observation protocol, short interviews or written responses, and a comparison with a neutral VR scene |
| VR works as a research medium, not only a display | Detailed description of the making process | A decision log showing what VR allowed the artist to find that paper maps did not |
Worked example: an illustrative doctoral design
The following design is illustrative and hypothetical. It shows how a doctoral candidate could build on this approach while meeting examination expectations.
- Question. How do the daily rhythms of residents of a coastal village change across a fishing season, and what can sensory mapping and immersive drawing reveal about them that interviews alone do not?
- Design. Rhythmanalysis (Lefebvre, 2004) as the analytic frame; sensory ethnography with eight to ten participants across two seasons, so that cyclical rhythms are actually observed rather than recalled.
- Documentation. A dated decision log for every map and VR drawing, with the source material for each mark, and photographs of work in progress.
- Member reflection. Draft maps returned to participants, with their responses recorded and reported.
- Audience strand. A short, consented post-viewing conversation with visitors, recorded with a simple protocol and analysed thematically.
- Ethics and access. University ethics approval, an identifiability plan agreed with participants, and an archive of the VR files, a video capture and software versions for examiners.
- Quality. A reflexive chapter addressing sincerity, credibility and resonance (Tracy, 2010).
What it means for doctoral researchers
Burns (2026) shows how a theoretical idea can shape every stage of a practice-based inquiry, from what participants are asked to record to how the final work moves. It also shows where such projects are most exposed at examination: the traceability of the translation from material to artwork, the evidence for claims about audiences and the ethics of working with identifiable people in small places. The wider argument for artistic research (Borgdorff, 2012; Loveless, 2019) does not lower the bar for evidence; it changes what the evidence looks like.
Common mistakes in practice-based doctoral research
- Presenting the artwork as the finding without showing how making produced the knowledge claimed.
- Keeping no record of creative decisions, so that the translation from data to work cannot be followed.
- Generalising from a handful of participants to a whole community.
- Reporting audience responses from memory rather than from a planned method.
- Assuming that creative or low-risk work needs no ethics review, or overlooking identifiability in small communities.
- Making outputs in software that may not open in a few years, with no archive or video capture.
Key takeaways
- Burns (2026) turns four islanders' recorded daily rhythms into an immersive VR drawing and soundscape, guided by rhythmanalysis (Lefebvre, 2004).
- The paper's strengths are a detailed account of making, theory that shapes the method and reciprocal consent.
- Claims about viewers' "perceptual contact" rest on informal observation and are best read as propositions for further study.
- Artistic research needs documentation that lets readers trace how material became work (Borgdorff, 2012).
- Doctoral projects of this kind should plan ethics review, identifiability, reflexivity (Tracy, 2010) and archiving from the start.
