The source and why it matters

This review examines Vang and Balslev Clausen (2025), "Grand challenges and supplier development in the Global South: why experiment with new (ethnographic) intervention research methods", which appeared in The International Journal of Logistics Management (volume 36, issue 4, pages 1136 to 1146). Both authors work in the Department of Culture and Learning at Aalborg University in Copenhagen. The piece is published as a viewpoint, and the authors state plainly that its purpose is to provoke new thinking, not to document empirical findings in depth.
The authors open with a diagnosis. Supply chain management (SCM), they argue, has reached a turning point: scholars are being asked to contribute to research on grand challenges and sustainability while keeping their work rigorous and theoretically grounded. Yet the bulk of SCM research concerns supply chains in the Global North. Vang and Balslev Clausen treat this as a serious blind spot, since the harm caused by climate change is expected to fall hardest on the Global South (Vang & Balslev Clausen, 2025).
Doctoral researchers in operations, logistics or development studies have two reasons to read the paper closely. First, it names a gap that a thesis could fill. Second, it poses a methodological problem that anyone studying suppliers in low-income settings must eventually face: how do we find out what is really happening on the ground, and what part should we play in changing it?
What the paper argues
The argument rests on the idea of grand challenges. These are large, global problems, such as climate change and inequality, that no single actor can solve and that call for coordinated effort (George et al., 2016). Vang and Balslev Clausen class them as wicked problems and conclude that they demand a methodology of their own. The term comes from Rittel and Webber (1973), who described planning problems that lack a definitive formulation, have no stopping rule and admit no solution that is simply true or false; with such problems, defining the issue and solving it are inseparable.
From this premise the authors propose ethnographic intervention research as a way to study grand challenges and suppliers in the Global South, and they offer four insights in its favour (Vang & Balslev Clausen, 2025). The approach joins two traditions. From ethnography it takes long, immersive fieldwork aimed at understanding practices on their own terms (Hammersley & Atkinson, 2019); to this it adds deliberate action to improve those practices.
To illustrate the proposal, the authors draw on their own projects in four settings: garment making in Bangladesh and Myanmar, tanning in Savar, coffee growing in Uganda and plastic waste handling in Old Dhaka. They contend that putting intervention at the centre commits researchers to real transformative work and equips them to design better interventions. They also describe their article as the first viewpoint to show how ethnographic interventionist methods can be applied in SCM (Vang & Balslev Clausen, 2025).
| Element | What the paper says |
|---|---|
| Problem | SCM research neglects suppliers in the Global South, where grand challenges bite hardest |
| Diagnosis | Grand challenges are wicked problems that conventional designs struggle to capture |
| Proposal | Ethnographic intervention research, supported by four insights |
| Illustrations | Garments (Bangladesh, Myanmar), tanning (Savar), coffee (Uganda), plastic waste (Old Dhaka) |
| Claimed value | Researchers engage in transformative activity; better-designed interventions |
| Genre | Viewpoint: intended to provoke thought, not to document evidence in depth |
Strengths
- It points to a genuine imbalance. Much of what we know about supplier sustainability in developing countries is seen from the buyer's desk or through audits. Research conducted inside supplier firms tells a different story: Huq et al. (2014) showed, for Bangladeshi garment factories, that codes written in the Global North can clash with local conditions and that compliance can be staged rather than practised.
- It redefines rigour as fit. The paper insists that method should follow the problem. In doing so it continues a long tradition of calls for qualitative and action-oriented research in logistics, a field whose problems are often messy and poorly structured (Näslund, 2002).
- It broadens supplier development. The classic literature studies how buying firms invest in their suppliers to raise cost, quality, delivery and flexibility performance (Krause et al., 2007). Vang and Balslev Clausen extend the idea to livelihoods, environmental damage and social outcomes.
- It draws on fieldwork. The illustrations are short, but they span several sectors and countries, so the argument comes from experience in the field rather than from the armchair.
Limitations and methodological issues
Any assessment has to start from the genre. A viewpoint exists to make a case, and this one is open about that aim. Readers should judge it on the strength and originality of its reasoning and cite it in that spirit. What it cannot do is show that ethnographic intervention research yields better knowledge, or better outcomes for suppliers, than the alternatives.
- Illustration rather than evidence. The projects serve as examples. Because the paper does not report how data were gathered and analysed, a reader cannot tell how firmly each illustration supports each claim, nor compare the cases in the way a systematic case design allows (Eisenhardt, 1989).
- A crowded methodological field. Researchers have intervened in the settings they study since the early days of action research (Lewin, 1946; Reason & Bradbury, 2008), including in operations management (Coughlan & Coghlan, 2002). SCM scholars have also proposed critical engaged research (Touboulic et al., 2020), and more recently process research has been offered as a lens for transformational issues such as sustainability (Grimm et al., 2024). The paper needs to say what its approach adds to these options, and its claim to be the first such viewpoint in SCM should be read with them in mind.
- Ethics in practice. Working with suppliers and workers who live in economic precarity raises questions of consent, power and positionality that an ethics committee's approval seldom resolves. Qualitative researchers separate procedural ethics from the ethically important moments that occur during fieldwork (Guillemin & Gillam, 2004). A methodological proposal of this kind would be stronger if it explained how such moments are handled.
- Quality criteria. Anyone who redefines rigour owes readers a way to judge the result. Criteria such as credibility, sincerity and relational ethics (Tracy, 2010) could serve, but a short viewpoint leaves little room to set them out.
- No account of outcomes over time. Recent work on farmer organisations in Uganda found that many are short-lived or exist mainly to receive subsidies (Nangobi et al., 2024). Interventions with supplier groups therefore raise a question of durability that the viewpoint does not address.
How the paper sits in the wider literature
Three strands of research frame the viewpoint. The first is management scholarship on grand challenges. George et al. (2016) laid out an agenda for studying how such challenges are formulated, articulated and implemented, and urged scholars to address them collaboratively. Vang and Balslev Clausen carry that agenda into supplier development in the Global South.
The second strand is the debate about method in SCM. Näslund (2002) argued that logistics needs qualitative as well as quantitative methods and singled out action research case studies as a good fit for its applied problems. Coughlan and Coghlan (2002) explained how to carry out action research in operations management, while Touboulic et al. (2020) described critical engaged research as an extended form of engaged research that widens how knowledge is produced in SCM. The viewpoint belongs in this conversation; its distinctive additions are an ethnographic emphasis and a focus on the Global South.
The third strand is empirical research on suppliers in developing countries. Huq et al. (2014) reported that the need to keep skilled workers drove social sustainability practices among Bangladeshi garment suppliers, that Western codes often sat poorly with local conditions, and that removing child labour from factories could push it into more dangerous industries. Findings of this kind show why researchers close to the field notice consequences that audits overlook, and that observation lies at the heart of Vang and Balslev Clausen's case.
What newer research adds (2024 to 2026)
Studies published since the viewpoint was submitted allow some of its premises to be checked. The table summarises seven of them, chosen because they address the sectors the authors name, the methodological debate they join, or the state of the wider field.
| Study | Design and data | Key finding | What it means for the reviewed paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| da Silva et al. (2025) | Systematic review of 485 Scopus articles on supply chains and sustainable development from the previous decade | Environmental sustainability is the most established theme; the authors call for circular economy research and more work on food supply chains | Shows where mainstream attention lies; the abstract does not single out Global South suppliers, consistent with the gap the viewpoint names |
| Grimm et al. (2024) | Methodological essay drawing on examples from SCM research | Process research methods suit the fluid, interwoven processes of supply chains and transformational issues such as sustainability | Offers a further alternative to conventional designs, so ethnographic intervention must show what it adds |
| Faroque et al. (2025) | Multiple embedded case study: two multinational lead buyers and four Bangladeshi garment suppliers; focus groups and key informant interviews | Workers face substantial obstacles to voice; buyers' roles are suboptimal, though short- and long-term buyer initiatives could help | Confirms that supplier-level fieldwork reveals problems codes miss; shows a non-interventionist design can do so |
| Rahman et al. (2026) | Cross-sectional survey of 400 workers at the Savar Tannery Industrial Estate; ordinal logistic regression | 87.5% of workers were concerned about health risks; knowledge strongly predicted concern, and inconsistent protective equipment use went with lower concern | Documents conditions in one of the viewpoint's own settings and identifies knowledge as a possible lever for intervention |
| Kishaija et al. (2025) | Bibliometric and systematic review of 95 studies (2013 to 2023) on smallholder coffee, climate change and livelihoods | Asset endowments shape adaptation; agroforestry is the main strategy; Fairtrade certification has mixed effects on income and well-being | Supports the claim that climate harm falls on Global South producers, and cautions that established interventions do not always deliver |
| Nangobi et al. (2024) | Cross-sectional data on 272 farmer organisations in 12 Ugandan districts; multilevel mixed-effects regression | Low sustainability index of 36%; finances, leadership and value-addition training matter | Raises the question of whether gains from interventions with supplier groups last |
| Solaja et al. (2024) | Cross-sectional survey of 183 informal plastic recyclers in Ogun State, Nigeria | 65% had never had safety equipment; 5% had formal contracts; 8% belonged to a union; 20% were fully aware of their rights | Shows how precarious informal waste work is in a comparable setting, sharpening the ethical demands on any intervention |
Much of the newer evidence supports the viewpoint's premises. The systematic review by da Silva et al. (2025) shows a field organised around environmental themes, circular economy and food waste, with no headline attention to the suppliers Vang and Balslev Clausen care about. Field studies in their own sectors document hardships that audits and codes leave unresolved: blocked worker voice in garment factories (Faroque et al., 2025), widespread health concern among tannery workers in Savar (Rahman et al., 2026) and poor protection in informal plastic recycling (Solaja et al., 2024). The coffee review confirms that climate change threatens smallholders, who produce most of the world's coffee (Kishaija et al., 2025).
The same evidence also complicates the argument. Most of these studies use surveys and case designs, not intervention, and they still reach ground-level problems. Access to hidden conditions is therefore not, on its own, a reason to intervene. The stronger case for intervention rests on the second half of the viewpoint's claim, that researchers can help design better interventions. Here the record is sobering: certification has mixed effects on coffee farmers (Kishaija et al., 2025), and many Ugandan farmer organisations do not endure (Nangobi et al., 2024). These findings show why interventions need careful evaluation. Meanwhile, Grimm et al. (2024) offer process research as a different answer to the same call for methods suited to transformation.
Several questions remain open. None of the newer studies reviewed here evaluates an ethnographic intervention in SCM, so the method's added value is still a proposal. Whether improvements outlast the researcher's presence, how workers themselves judge interventions, and how buyers respond when findings challenge them are all unanswered, and each could anchor a doctoral study.
What it means for doctoral researchers
For a doctoral researcher the paper works best as a statement of a gap and as a methodological challenge. Read alongside the newer studies, it is most useful when paired with empirical work that tests its premises. The table shows how to cite it accurately.
| If you want to... | Use Vang and Balslev Clausen (2025) to... | Pair it with... |
|---|---|---|
| Justify a Global South focus | Show that SCM research concentrates on the Global North | Empirical studies of suppliers in your region and sector, such as recent work on garments and tanning (Faroque et al., 2025; Rahman et al., 2026) |
| Justify a qualitative or interventionist design | Argue that wicked problems need methods fitted to them | Action research, engaged research and process research sources (Coughlan & Coghlan, 2002; Touboulic et al., 2020; Grimm et al., 2024) |
| Discuss rigour | Show that the field is debating what rigour means | Explicit quality criteria for your chosen approach |
| Claim effectiveness of a method | Not appropriate: the viewpoint does not test it | Empirical evaluations, or frame the claim as a proposal |
Worked example (illustrative)
Consider a hypothetical candidate who wants to study how smallholder coffee cooperatives in East Africa respond to buyers' sustainability requirements. In her literature review she cites the viewpoint to show that supplier perspectives from the Global South are under-represented in SCM. She adds Huq et al. on garment suppliers as an empirical parallel, and the review by Kishaija et al. to show that certification has had mixed effects on coffee farmers.
She then weighs three designs: a multiple case study, participatory action research with one cooperative, and an ethnographic intervention in which she joins a cooperative's training programme. If she chooses the third, she records in advance what she will change, who takes decisions, how members can opt out, and how she will distinguish her own influence from other causes of change. Mindful of the Ugandan evidence that many farmer organisations are short-lived, she also plans a follow-up visit after leaving the field. Whichever route she takes, the viewpoint has helped her frame the gap and state her methodological reasoning openly, which is the right way to use it.
The paper and the newer evidence also suggest research questions. How do suppliers judge the interventions designed with them? Do gains made during an ethnographic intervention persist after the researcher has gone? How do buyers, auditors and local regulators react when findings unsettle their assumptions? Each question turns the viewpoint's proposal into a researchable problem, a step the authors leave to their readers.
For more on positioning a study against existing work, see our guidance on research gap identification.
Common mistakes when citing a viewpoint
- Reporting a viewpoint's illustrations as if they were systematic findings.
- Citing a single viewpoint as the sole justification for a methodological choice.
- Adopting a label such as "ethnographic intervention research" without explaining how it differs from action research, engaged research or process research.
- Treating intervention as ethically neutral because institutional approval has been granted.
- Assuming that an intervention such as certification works without citing evidence of its effects.
- Ignoring the buyer side entirely when the research question concerns buyer and supplier relations.
- Quoting the abstract's claims without reading the full text.
Key takeaways
- Vang and Balslev Clausen (2025) argue that SCM neglects Global South suppliers and propose ethnographic intervention research for studying grand challenges.
- Grand challenges are framed as wicked problems, which the authors see as needing methods fitted to them (Rittel & Webber, 1973; George et al., 2016).
- The paper is a viewpoint: its field projects illustrate the argument but do not test the method.
- Studies from 2024 to 2026 confirm hardships in the sectors it names, yet mostly reach them without intervention, and show that interventions such as certification have mixed effects (Faroque et al., 2025; Rahman et al., 2026; Kishaija et al., 2025).
- Its contribution is clearest when read alongside action research, critical engaged research and process research in SCM (Näslund, 2002; Touboulic et al., 2020; Grimm et al., 2024).
- Doctoral researchers can cite it to establish a gap and frame method choices, paired with empirical studies such as Huq et al. (2014).
