Important factors to consider when evaluating a reference for an academic article / dissertation

Literature Review

Important factors to consider when evaluating a reference for an academic article / dissertation

Content:

  1. Good arguments
  2. Shows evidence for claims
  3. Reliable
  4. Shows Limitations
  5. Biased
  6. Strong Content
  7. Weak content

Context in discipline

  1. Landmark article
  2. A useful contribution to the field
  3. Agrees with current thought
  4. Contradicts current thought
  5. Good Introduction to the field

Methodology

  1. Strong reasoning
  2. Replication possible
  3. Adequate sample size

Author

  1. Good academic standing
  2. Refers to other authors
  3. Writing easy to understand

Relevance

    1. Recent Publication
    2. Reliable source
    3. Same purpose as your own research
    4. Relevant to your study
    5. The country where the research was conducted relates to your own research